UI-2023-000261
- Case title:
- Appellant name:
- Status of case: Unreported
- Hearing date:
- Promulgation date:
- Publication date:
- Last updated on:
- Country:
- Judges:
The decision
IN THE UPPER TRIBUNAL
IMMIGRATION AND ASYLUM
CHAMBER Case No: UI-2023-000261
First-tier Tribunal No: PA/01225/2020
THE IMMIGRATION ACTS
Decision & Reasons Issued:
On 3 November 2026
Before
UPPER TRIBUNAL JUDGE MANDALIA
Principal Resident Judge
Between
KD
(ANONYMITY DIRECTION MADE)
Appellant
and
Secretary of State for the Home Department
Respondent
Representation
For the Appellant: Jennifer Lanigan, counsel, instructed by Virgo Solicitors Ltd
For the Respondent: Arifa Ahmed, Senior Home Office Presenting Officer and
Amerjit Singh Basra
Heard at Field House on 5 August 2026
Decision and Reasons
Anonymity
1. This appellant has previously made a claim for international protection. Pursuant to rule 14 of the Tribunal Procedure (Upper Tribunal) Rules 2008, the appellant is granted anonymity. No-one shall publish or reveal any information, including the name or address of the appellant, likely to lead members of the public to identify the appellant. Failure to comply with this order could amount to a contempt of court.
Introduction
2. The appellant is a national of Turkey. He arrived in the United Kingdom clandestinely on 19 August 2001, aged 30. He made a claim for International protection in August 2001 that was refused by the respondent. An appeal against that decision was dismissed by Adjudicator, Mr Graeme Peart for reasons set out in a decision promulgated on 26 September 2004. The appellant nevertheless remained in the UK unlawfully.
3. On 12 December 2007 the appellant was convicted at the Central Criminal Court for the murder of his wife following a trial. The appellant was sentenced to life imprisonment, with a minimum term of 12 years.
4. On 1 December 2016, the appellant was notified that section 32(5) of the UK Borders Act 2007 places a duty on the respondent to make a deportation order against him unless he can demonstrate that one or more of the specified exceptions set out in section 33 of that Act applies to him. Having considered representations made on the appellant’s behalf, on 23 January 2019, the respondent informed the appellant that his asylum and human rights claims had been refused. The respondent said:
a. The appellant has failed to rebut the presumption in section 72 of the Nationality, Immigration and Asylum Act 2002 (“the 2002 Act”) that the crime he committed was particularly serious and he is a danger to the community. The respondent therefore certified that the presumption in s72(9)(b) applies.
b. The appellant’s fear that if returned to Turkey, his life would be in danger as a result of a blood feud does not engage the United Kingdom’s obligations under the 1951 United Nations Convention relating to the Status of Refugees. In any event, the appellant’s claim is rejected. Furthermore, the background material establishes that the perpetrators of any such blood feud would face justice and imprisonment. The appellant can approach the police for protection if required and could live elsewhere in Turkey.
c. The appellant is excluded from humanitarian protection because there are serious reasons for considering that he constitutes a danger to the community or to the security of the United Kingdom.
d. The appellant’s deportation would not be contrary to the European Convention on Human Rights (“ECHR”).
5. The appellant’s appeal against that decision was allowed by the First-tier Tribunal (“FtT”), and the decision of the FtT was upheld on appeal to the Upper Tribunal. The respondent was granted permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal set aside the decisions of the FtT and Upper Tribunal for reasons set out in a judgment dated 23 March 2026 ([2026] EWCA Civ 349). For present purposes it is sufficient to simply record that Lord Justice Jackson (with whom Lord Justice Arnold and Lord Justice Dove agreed) held:
a. The section 72 presumption has not been displaced and the appellant is therefore not eligible for the protection of the Refugee Convention.
b. The 2004 assessment by Adjudicator, Mr Graeme Peart of the appellant’s political activities is to be treated as authoritative, and his asylum and human rights appeals on the basis of imputed political opinion should be dismissed.
c. The FtT did not make comprehensive findings as to the alleged blood feud and the appeal is remitted to the Upper Tribunal for that issue to be determined with no findings preserved.
Application for an Adjournment
6. Given the unfortunate delays that have already occurred, the Court of Appeal recorded in its order that there is a request to the President of the Upper Tribunal that the matter be appropriately allocated and expedited to the extent he considers appropriate.
7. Following remittal to the Upper Tribunal on 25 March 2026, I issued directions directing that the appeal will be listed for an expedited hearing on the first available date. I made directions for the appellant’s representatives to file and serve a composite bundle, to include evidence to be relied upon by the appellant that was not previously relied upon before the FtT. The appeal was listed for hearing before the Upper Tribunal on 22 April 2026. Thereafter:
a. On 9 April 2026, the appellant’s solicitors requested an adjournment because counsel, who has represented the appellant at the FtT, the UT and Court of Appeal was unavailable on 22 April 2026. The application was refused by the Upper Tribunal Lawyer on 13 August 2026. She noted, inter alia, that there is no evidence to show that the appellant could not fairly or effectively present his, case by instructing alternative counsel and that an adjournment would cause unnecessary delay.
b. On 16 April 2026 the Upper Tribunal received an email from the Presenting Officer indicating that the parties may not be in a position to proceed to the full hearing listed on 22 April 2026 and invited the Tribunal to treat the hearing as a case management review hearing. On 16 April 2026 Upper Tribunal Judge Loughran directed that the hearing on 22 April 2026 be converted to a case management hearing.
c. On 22 April 2026, Directions were given by Judge Loughran for the filing of further evidence in readiness for the hearing of the appeal. She noted in her order that the appellant intended to rely on updated witness evidence from himself, his brother and his second cousin and that the appellant also intended to rely on a country expert report addressing the prevalence of blood feuds in Turkey, the plausibility of the appellant’s account, and whether sufficiency of protection and internal relocation would be available to the appellant in Turkey. An appropriate expert had not yet been identified. She acceded to the request made for a further two months to obtain the evidence, and directed that the appeal will be relisted for hearing on the first available date after 22 July 2026.
d. On 1 May 2026 Virgo Solicitors informed the respondent that Dr Kaveh Ghobadi has been identified as an appropriate expert and that he has indicated that a report can be completed within 5 weeks. On the same day, an email was sent by Mr Basra to the appellant’s solicitors requesting confirmation that the expert has been instructed, and the date by which the report would be available.
e. On 2 July 2026, further directions were issued by Judge Loughran. In the recitals to her order she noted that the appellant had not complied with the directions previously made and that the appeal has been listed for hearing on 5 August 2026. She varied the directions previously made to give the appellant an opportunity to file and serve any further evidence to be relied upon, by 10 July 2026. She directed the appellant to file and serve a composite bundle by 4pm on 29 July 2026.
f. On 7 July 2026, the parties were served with a Notice of Hearing confirming the appeal is listed for hearing on 5 August 2026.
g. On 24 July 2026 the respondent filed her skeleton argument in readiness for the hearing on 5 August 2026. The respondent made express reference in that skeleton argument to the failure of the appellant and his representatives to comply with the directions previously made by the Tribunal. The respondent also expressly stated she will strongly resist any application, if made, to rely on late evidence and/ or adjourn the hearing listed.
h. On 3 August 2026 (at 21:14 hrs), Virgo Solicitors emailed the Upper Tribunal requesting an adjournment of the hearing listed. The application was accompanied by three statements of witnesses all of which are said to have been signed on 7 July 2026. The Tribunal was also provided with a statement made by Mr Glenn Corney, who is described as a Caseworker at Virgo Solicitors Ltd with responsibility for the appellant’s case.
8. Mr Corney apologies “profusely” for his failure to comply with the directions issued and claims he has “experienced professional and personal constraints” that have impacted on his dealing with the directions. Mr Corney claims in his statement that initially this was due to a loss of contact with the appellant. Communication with the appellant had been facilitated by his brother, Ali Dogan (“ALD”). Mr Corney claims ALD changed his telephone number and failed to inform him. He experienced a few months delay in progressing the matter because he was unable to contact the appellant’s brother. He managed to contact ALD via third parties and arranged to obtain the supplementary statements that the appellant now seeks to rely upon. Mr Corney also refers to a personal matter that he has had to address since “the turn of the year” that is set out in his statement and I do not repeat here. He states that he sought to keep on top of his work without seeking the necessary help and assistance from his employer, Dr. Abess Taqi, but candidly acknowledges that he has failed. Mr Corney claims that he confirmed with Dr. Taqi that he had contacted Country Experts and that he was in regular contact with counsel to seek guidance when necessary. Mr Corney claims Dr. Taqi agreed to review the case with him on 20 July 2026 but unfortunately, that date coincided with his annual family holidays. Dr. Taqi agreed to review Mr Corney’s work whilst Mr Corney was away. His supervisor realised without being aware of Mr Corney’s professional and personal constraints (as he had not informed him of those matters) that the court’s directions have not been complied with.
9. The respondent filed a response to the application for an adjournment and on 4 August 2026, the parties were informed that the application for an adjournment is refused and the hearing of the appeal will proceed as listed. The application for an adjournment was renewed by Ms Lanigan at the hearing before me. She submitted, in summary, that there are clearly issues as to the preparation for the hearing of the appeal. She was bound to acknowledge that the appellant's solicitors have failed to comply with any of the directions previously issued by the Tribunal. Responsibility for the failures rests, Ms Lanigan submits, entirely with the appellant’s solicitors and it is in the interests of justice and fairness to the appellant, that the hearing be adjourned so that the expert evidence can be obtained and any further evidence relied upon by the appellant can properly be filed and served. She said that the appellant had not been asked by his representatives whether he wanted to provide further evidence and having spoken to the appellant in conference that morning, she understands the appellant has supporting information from the Turkish authorities regarding recent events. The application was opposed by the respondent.
10. The underlying decision of the respondent that is the subject of this appeal is dated 23 January 2019. The appeal has already suffered from significant delays as can seen from the chronology that I have set out at paragraphs [5] to [7] of this decision. Mr Corney takes responsibility for the failure to comply with the directions made by the Tribunal, but as he sets out in his statement, there was also a failure by the appellant and/or his brother to maintain contact with those acting for the appellant. It was incumbent on the appellant, who despite his vulnerabilities, has the support of his brothers in the UK to ensure that he took proper steps to progress the appeal.
11. I have borne in mind the potentially grave consequences for the appellant whose very life may be put at risk by an adverse decision and the need to allow the appellant to put forward relevant and potentially cogent evidence in favour of his appeal. As McCloskey J said in Nwaigwe (adjournment: fairness) [2014] UKUT 00418 (IAC), it is a fundamental common law right of every litigant to a fair hearing, and fairness is the overriding consideration.
12. The issue that is to be determined by me in this appeal could not have been more clearly set out by the Court of Appeal ([2026] EWCA Civ 349). The need for further evidence must have been apparent to the appellant and his representatives. The respondent objected to a lengthy adjournment at the case management review hearing, but Judge Loughran gave sufficient time for the expert report that the appellant wished to rely upon to be obtained. The appellant and his representatives were also plainly aware of the need for further evidence. Statements were signed by two of the appellant’s brothers on 7 July 2026. One of those statements is made by ALD, the brother of the appellant who is relied upon by Mr Corney to contact the appellant and communicate with him. A statement was also signed on the same date by Mahmut Hirli. Although Ms Lanigan submitted the witnesses had not attended the hearing and were unaware of the hearing, there was sufficient time for arrangements to be made for their attendance. As will become apparent later in this decision, they were able to attend, and did attend.
13. As was said by the Upper Tribunal in Dawrani (Judicial discretion – late evidence – sanction) [2026] UKUT00151 (IAC), albeit in the context of the admission of late evidence, the Tribunal is the guardian of precious and limited judicial time and resources in circumstances where there are many others awaiting decisions in their proceedings. The Tribunal will not blindly tolerate flagrant procedural failings. Those who appear in this jurisdiction must understand that procedural requirements and case management directions are to be taken seriously and that serious consequences may flow from breaches.
14. The credibility of the claim made by the appellant is one for me, and there is a wealth of background material regarding ‘blood feuds’. There is in my judgement, no reason, let alone good reason, to adjourn the hearing of the appeal. The appellant is represented. The parties are under a duty to help the Upper Tribunal to further the overriding objective and cooperate with the Upper Tribunal generally. The overriding objective is to deal with cases fairly and justly, in ways which are proportionate to the importance of the case, the complexity of the issues, and the anticipated costs and resources of the parties. As set out in Rule 2(2)(e) of the Tribunal Procedure (Upper Tribunal) Rules 2008, dealing with cases fairly and justly includes avoiding delay so far as compatible with proper consideration of the issues. It is neither in public interest, nor the interests of the appellant for there to be ongoing delay in the determination of such an appeal and I refused the application for an adjournment.
The Application to Admit Further Evidence
15. Ms Lanigan sought permission to rely upon three witness statement that were provided to the Tribunal and to the respondent under cover of the email sent to the Tribunal on 3 August 2026 (at 21:14 hrs) by Virgo Solicitors. They are statements made by the appellant’s brothers, Riza Dogan (“RZD”) and ALD, and a statement made by Mahmut Hirli. Each of the statements are dated 7 July 2026. Ms Lanigan submits that although the statements have not been filed in accordance with the directions made and there is no obvious explanation for the failure to serve the statements after they were signed on 7 July 2026, the statements are relevant to the central issue in this appeal, namely the on-going risk to the appellant as a result of a blood feud.
16. Although the application to rely upon that further evidence was opposed by Ms Ahmed, I gave permission for the appellant to rely upon that evidence. I accept the failure to serve the evidence relied upon is a significant and serious breach of the directions made by the Tribunal. Equally, I accept, as Ms Ahmed submits, that there is no good reason for the failure to comply with the directions. The failings of his representatives alone is not a good reason. I must however consider all the circumstances and Ms Ahmed, quite properly in my judgment, acknowledged that the statements are brief and the respondent would not suffer any disadvantage because she and Mr Basra were able to deal with the statements and would have the opportunity to cross-examine two of the witnesses who are in the UK. They could reasonably be expected to attend the hearing.
The Application to treat the appellant as a Vulnerable Witness
17. I was invited by Ms Lanigan to treat the appellant as a vulnerable witness. She referred to a letter provided by Derman, dated 25 October 2021 which confirms that the appellant had been referred by his GP “in the last two years” for depression, anxiety and suicidal ideation issues. He was assessed on 14 May 2021 and was offered 12 weeks of counselling sessions that commenced in September 2021. The letter confirms that the appellant was “confined in small places for a long time under constant threat” which the author of the letter believes, led to symptoms similar to PTSD. When the appellant communicates with people he does not know well, he develops panic attacks during which he cannot breathe or talk. My attention was also drawn to evidence of medication taken by the appellant that includes Mirtazapine.
18. There is no evidence at all of any formal diagnosis of any mental health condition, cognitive deficits or memory loss. Although there is no recent formal diagnosis regarding the appellant’s mental health, nor any evidence before the Tribunal regarding the counselling sessions the appellant presumably attended, it was evident that the appellant had already had to step out of the hearing room during the morning. There is no evidence before me regarding the ability of the appellant to give evidence in support of his appeal or what, if any, adjustments were required to enable him to do so. Ms Lanigan suggested that by way of reasonable adjustments, the appellant should be permitted to have regular breaks so that he can take a step outside. That suggestion was adopted during the course of the hearing. The appellant was given appropriate breaks when he was giving evidence. I have also had regard to the Joint Presidential Guidance Note No.2 of 2010: Child, Vulnerable Adult and Sensitive Appellant Guidance, and my assessment of the appellant’s credibility has been considered in the round, taking due account of the evidence before me.
The Evidence
19. I was provided with a composite bundle comprising of 443 pages that had been prepared previously but not updated. I was also provided with copies of the three further witness statements that the appellant relies upon. They are statements signed on 7 July 2026 by two of the appellant’s brothers and Mahmut Hirli that I refer to at paragraph [15] above. I heard oral evidence from the appellant, ALD and Mahmut Hirli. Each of them gave their evidence with the assistance of an interpreter arranged by the Tribunal, who translated the English and Turkish languages.
The Appellant
20. The appellant adopted his previous witness statements dated 6 September 2016 and 19 October 2020. Although a witness statement should be capable of standing as the totality of the evidence-in-chief, there is no further witness statement from the appellant. I permitted Ms Lanigan to ask a few supplementary questions only to bring his evidence up to date. The appellant confirmed he takes medication for panic attacks and high blood pressure. He is prescribed Mirtazapine, Propranolol, Amlodipine and Amioditine. The appellant confirmed he had not been asked by his solicitors to provide a further statement. He said that some documents were sent to him from Turkey that he provided to his solicitor. He claims the documents relate to an attack on his paternal uncle’s child, maternal uncle’s child and his nephew. The documents were statements taken at the Gendarme station. When asked about the most recent incident that had occurred in the blood feud, the appellant said that his paternal uncle’s son, Behcet Dogan (BTD”) was shot about four months ago. The appellant said that his brother told him of the attack and said that they were shot by a relative of his deceased wife. The appellant said that his 19 year old nephew was also stopped and attacked by a 22 year old male. His nephew has been unable to return to school because he is scared.
21. In cross-examination, the appellant said that he was told about the most recent incident that occurred four or five months ago by his brother RZD. He said he had been told about the incident two to two and a half months ago. He had previously asked if there had been any incident and he was not told of any. The appellant confirmed that he was told in about May 2026. He has read the most recent statement signed by Riaz Dogan on 7 July 2026 and accepted that the attack is not referred to. The appellant denied he had made up the claimed attack.
22. The appellant confirmed that he remains in danger from his deceased wife’s family because they blame him for her death. He maintained that three members of his family were killed previously. The appellant added that his brother, Erdal Dogan (“ELD”) was recently sent a text asking him when the appellant would be returning. The appellant accepted ELD has not made a statement. He claimed ELD had sent him a message saying that he was receiving threats. The appellant claims he forwarded the text messages to his solicitors. The appellant accepted that he has not provided any of the messages in which threats are made. He said that his family is verbally threatened by lots of people. He confirmed he has not spoken to his deceased wife's family since her death and a number of MPs and District Officers have tried to stop the blood feud but his deceased wife's family will not agree. The threats and incidents have been reported by the appellant's family to the Gendarme, at the police station and to the village Muhtar.
23. The appellant said that the attacks on his family have occurred in Turkcayryi and in Afsin. His deceased wife’s family live in Afsin. The distance between the two is about 35 to 40km. The appellant confirmed that the village Muhtar of the Afsin district, Huseyin Dogan has provided two statements confirming the appellant will be at risk because he killed his wife and confirming there has been no reconciliation between the parties. The appellant confirmed that Huseyin Dogan, the village Muhtar is the maternal uncle of his deceased wife. He has been begging the families to make peace and stop the blood feud. He is also related to the appellant. The appellant’s grandfather and Huseyin Dogan’s grandfather are brothers.
24. When it was put to the appellant that his deceased wife’s family do not have the reach to find him elsewhere in Turkey, the appellant claimed that he could easily be found by the payment of a bribe. He said that if you pay a police officer 1000 Lira, the officer would be able to find you. The appellant was referred to his evidence before the Adjudicator, Mr Peart in 2004 in which he claimed, at [22], that he had moved to Istanbul in July 2000 to live with his maternal aunt. He said that was correct, but he claimed he is not sure where his maternal aunt is now and he does not know whether she is still alive. When asked why he could not go and live in Istanbul now, he said that he would if it can be guaranteed that if he is deported, nothing will happen to him.
25. The appellant confirmed that the attack on his relatives in 2008 was one in which three people were murdered and his niece, who I refer to as GND was also injured. The attack was conducted by Hasan Dogan, as set out in the ‘Non Jurisdiction Order’ that appears to be dated 7 October 2008. The appellant accepted that the ‘Non Jurisdiction Order’ [197] refers to the death of the victim arising from an injury with a hunting rifle and there being no reference to a blood feud. He said that there was no reason for the document to refer to a blood feud and that there is no other reason why they would have killed members of the appellant’s family. The appellant was referred to a decision of the FtT (PA/54446/2021) concerning an appellant, MD. There is reference in paragraph [5] of that decision to Yusuf Dogan having been granted refugee status in the UK. The appellant said that the Yusuf Dogan referred to in that decision is his nephew and the same person who was shot in Turkey.
26. The appellant claimed that he would not be able to access the medication that he is prescribed in Turkey.
27. In re-examination, the appellant said that he does not know how the recent statement made by his brother RZD was prepared and why he does not refer to the most recent incident. The appellant said that his solicitors have not asked his brother ELD to provide a statement. He claimed that his deceased wife’s family have not contacted him directly because they do not know his contact number. The appellant said that a local MP had got involved about three or four years ago to stop the blood feud. He said that about seven months ago, other officials including army officials had also gone to try and make peace but that did not work. The appellant said that he has provided the names of the members of his deceased wife’s family that have attacked his family to his solicitors and he does not know why that information has not been set out in the witness statements. The appellant said that attacks were carried out by Hasan Dogan, Thylan Dogan, Ismail Doga and Ismail’s son. The appellant was referred to the reference to Yusuf Dogan in paragraph [5] of the decision of the FtT (PA/54446/2021) relating to MD. The appellant believes that appeal related to his nephew [MD] and clarified that the ‘Yusuf Dogan’ referred to in that decision is different to the ‘Yusuf Dogan’ that the appellant refers to as having been killed in 2008. When asked by Ms Lanigan about living in Istanbul, the appellant maintained that “If the UK state guarantees nothing will happen, I will go”. He does not know the distance between Afsin and Istanbul, but he maintains that if he went to live in Istanbul, they would definitely find him, because his deceased wife’s family have lots or relatives there.
Ali Dogan (“ALD”)
28. ALD is the brother of the appellant. He adopted his witness statements dated 6 October 2016 [292], 8 April 2021 [119], 19 July 2022 [153] and 7 July 2026. He confirmed the content of each of those statement is true and accurate.
29. In cross-examination, he confirmed that the manuscript note [207] setting out the names of the appellant’s family that is in the appellant’s bundle appears to have been prepared by RZD although he does not know when it was prepared. ALD confirmed his account in paragraph [2] of his statement dated 8 April 2021 that their relatives Yusuf Dogan, Imdat Bagdanli and GND were attacked in 2008 and that Yusuf and Imdat were killed, is correct. ALD said that he has a nephew named Yusuf Dogan (his elder sister’s son) and also a paternal cousin whose name is also Yusuf Dogan. His paternal cousin lives in the UK. ALD confirmed that he arrived in the UK on 24 December 1990 and so he did not personally witness the incident in 2008, but he watched the funeral of his nephew that was attended by all his family, on his phone. He said that his nephew was shot and taken to the hospital. He could not be saved and he was buried straight away.
30. ALD confirmed that he was aware of some incidents that happened four or five months ago. He accepted he did not refer to any such incidents in his statement signed in July 2026. He claimed they had given all the documents to the appellant’s solicitor. He claimed that he had written his statement in Turkish and sent the statement to the interpreter, who translated it and sent it to the solicitors.
31. In re-examination, ALD said that he had provided information about all the incidents to the solicitors, and that the solicitor also knows about the recent events. He maintained that the statement was prepared by him in Turkish and was translated. He said that he was told about the shooting of his nephew, Yusuaf, by his brother and other relatives. He was told that his family think Yusuf was shot by Hasan Dogan.
32. When asked about the last incident that has occurred by Ms Lanigan, ALD said that his brother ELD was taking his daughter to school. When they were in the car, the appellant’s deceased wife’s family put a huge rock in front of the car to stop the car. His brother changed direction and tried to go a different way. There were people waiting with guns. His brother managed to run away and went to the Gendarme. He said that the incident occurred between three and five months ago. He was told about it by his brother, ELD.
Mahmut Hirli
33. Mahmut Hirli is from the same village as the appellant in Turkcayiri. He adopted his witness statements dated 23 November 2021 [192], and 7 July 2026. He confirmed the content of each of those statement is true and accurate. He left Turkey on 30 June 2020 and arrived in the UK on 26 August 2020. He claims that when he was in Turkey, he heard about the blood feud between the two families following the death of the appellant’s wife.
34. In cross-examination, Mahmut Hirli confirmed that the appellant’s family and his deceased wife’s family share the same surname and they are all distant relatives. He claimed he was twelve or thirteen years old at the time of the murder and he would hear arguments about the blood feud. He claimed that he had witnessed Yusuf Dogan attack the other family. Mahmut Hirli said that he was in his early teens at the time and recalls that it was about summer time. He said that he was young at the time He said that he witnessed some shouting and arguments and that he saw the attack. He was asked why he had not referred to an attack by Yusuf in his witness statement. He said that he is referring to things that happened during his teenage years. That attack was about ten to fifteen years ago.
35. Mr Hirli was asked whether he is aware of any more recent attacks against the appellant’s family. He said that he had been told by his father that there was an attack and a shooting. He was told that someone had stopped a car. The police were called and it was reported to the police. Mr Hirli said that his father had informed him of that attack about three or four months ago when the incident took place. Asked why the incident is not referred to in his witness statement dated 7 July 2026, he claimed that the appellant's solicitors were notified but for some reason they did not refer to it. Mr Hirli was asked again about his claim that he had witnesses Yusuf Dogan attack someone from the other family. He said that he was young at the time and he had witnessed Yusuf attack ELD who is the appellant’s younger brother. He claimed that Yusuf was the appellant’s deceased wife’s brother. He claimed that Yusuf Dogan is against the appellant in the blood feud and that the attack had taken place in the village in Turkey. The Yusuf Dogan he is referring to is the appellant’s deceased wife’s brother. Mr Hirli maintained that the appellant has caused a blood feud that is well know and continues.
36. In re-examination Mr Hirli claimed that the incident that he is referring to when Yusuf attacked ELD, was to his recollection, an incident when Yusuf came to the door and he attacked and punched ELD. As far as the recent incident is concerned, he did not ask his father about any protection being provided to the appellant’s family by the police. He said that he had referred to the recent attack when he spoke to the appellant’s solicitor and the statement was being prepared. He stated that the solicitor and interpreter were present. The interpreter was writing down what Mr Hirli had said and the interpreter then told the solicitor. The interpreter read back to him what had been said.
37. For clarification, I reminded Mr Hirli that he refers to his father having recently told him about an attack and a shooting. I asked him whether they were one or two incidents. Mr Hirli said it was one incident and what his father told him didn’t involve a shooting. He only told him about ‘stopping the car and the attack of BTD’. He was told that there were some guns involved, although nobody was shot. There were some people aiming guns when and they “let them off the car”. I asked who, and the appellant said that ELD was definitely there but he does not know who else was in the car.
38. After I heard the evidence, the hearing had to be adjourned so that I could hear the parties submissions. The appeal was listed for further hearing before me on 19 August 2026 to hear the parties submissions.
Submissions
39. On behalf of the respondent, I have a skeleton argument settled by Ms Ahmed. I heard submissions from both Ms Ahmed and Ms Lanigan, which are a matter of record. In reaching my decision I have had regard to the submissions both in writing and at the hearing before me although I have not found it necessary to refer to each and every point which they raised.
40. In summary, Ms Ahmed relies upon the respondent’s decision letter. She submits the appellant and his witnesses are not credible. Ms Ahmed submits the appellant claims that his representatives are responsible for the lack of evidence before the Tribunal, but the appellant and his family are familiar with the ‘tribunal process’ and the appellant will have known of the importance of the hearing of his appeal. The appellant has the support of members of his family and the evidence is that the witness statements were read to the authors before they were signed. The witnesses do not refer to any recent evidence of the appellant’s family being targeted in the witness statements filed recently.
41. Ms Ahmed submits that in the list of family members that is relied upon by the appellant [207] there is reference to Yusuf Dogan. He is described as the appellant’s nephew (the son of the appellant’s elder sister). The list of family members refers to members of the appellant’s family and members of his deceased wife’s family, albeit they are inter-related. Ms Ahmed submits the evidence of Mr Hirli is that Yusaf Dogan is the brother of the appellant’s deceased wife. There is no reference to any other ‘Yusuf Dogan’ in the list of family members relied upon by the appellant. There is however reference to a Yusuf Dogan in paragraph [5] of the decision of the FtT (PA/54446/2021) relating to MD that appears in the appellant’s bundle. Ms Ahmed submits that is evidence of Yusuf Ahmed having been granted refugee status in the UK and entirely undermines the appellant’s case that he was killed in 2008.
42. Ms Ahmed submits the appellant’s deceased wife was a ‘distant relative’ of the appellant and the appellant’s family and the family of his deceased wife share the same surname. The village Muhtar, Huseyin Dogan is a relative of the appellant’s deceased wife. She submits there is a lack of background material to establish that blood feud’s are pursued amongst the extended family. The blood feud is not referred to in the determinations that are relied upon by the appellant relating to others. The appellant’s cousin, Ahmet Dogan (“ATD”), has provided a statement [151] dated 7 June 2022 but has not attended the hearing to give evidence. Ms Ahmed submits it is a significant omission that in his appeal heard on 30 May 2019, ATD made no reference to the blood feud. She submits I should reject his evidence that he considered it better not to refer to the appellant and the blood feud because the appellant was in prison at the time and that he considered it better not to connect his name to the name of the appellant at the time.
43. Ms Ahmed submits that as a starting point, I should have in mind the adverse credibility finding already made against the appellant by Adjudicator, Mr Peart in 2004 The appellant was found to be hesitant, confused, vague and evasive. The appellant was found to have submitted a “wholly fraudulent asylum application with no truthful foundation”. Ms Ahmed submits the appellant and his witnesses remain unimpressive. The evidence was unclear. She submits I should attach little weigh to the evidence of Hasan Kaygisiz, who claims to be an Advocate in Turkey. He simply relies upon information provided by the appellant’s family. The village Muhtar, Huseyin Dogan, is a relative of the appellant’s deceased wife and if there is a genuine blood feud, it is incredible that he would write letters to support the appellant’s claim.
44. Ms Ahmed referred me to extracts from the Daily Sabah published on 28 October 2024 which cites two prominent families in the southeastern province of Sanhurfa bringing together an unlikely alliance of mediators who achieved peace between the two families. She also referred me to extracts from a book – ‘How formal Institutions Matter’ published by the University of Michigan Press in 2023. In a chapter addressing ‘Cem Courts’ the author addresses the role of informal institutions in conflict resolution, particularly amongst the Alevi community in Turkey. A community and religious leader can provide assistance to the parties in resolving their differences or as an arbitrator. The Cem Court originate from communal beliefs, traditions and norms rather than formal, official law, and decisions are enforced through informal communal and social mechanisms. It seems, informal justice mechanisms have been highly institutionalised within the Alevi community, albeit that urbanisation has had a negative impact on Alevi traditions and institutions.
45. Ms Ahmed submits that although the background material establishes that blood feuds can exist, particularly in rural areas, they are now rare. In any event, even if there is a blood feud, there is a sufficiency of protection for the appellant and internal relocation would not be unduly harsh. The account relied upon by the appellant and his witnesses is that the police have been called and they have responded. The appellant is unable to establish that he is unable to turn to the relevant authorities for protection. Ms Ahmed refers to the CPIN; Turkey: Kurds published in July 2025 which indicates that the state can provide effective protection against non-state actors, including rogue state-actors. It is said that Kurds may be reluctant to report incidents due to a low level of trust in the police, but that is not the same as the state's unwillingness to provide protection. The Constitution states that all individuals are equal, regardless of language, race, or other factors, and there are legal and administrative ways to complain about discrimination, which is prohibited under the law. The CPIN confirms that where a person is at risk from a non-state actor, internal relocation is likely to be reasonable. There are Kurdish communities throughout Turkey and Turkish citizens are free to move throughout the country. The attacks relied upon by the appellant are confined to Turkcayryi and Afsin. The appellant confirmed in 2004 that he and his now deceased wife moved to the Kucukarmutlu district of Istanbul where he had family. The appellant has been absent from Turkey since 2001 but speaks Turkish and has skills and support that he can rely upon on return. Ms Ahmed submits I should reject the appellant’s account that he does not know whether his aunt is still alive. The appellant has clearly received support in the past from a close knit family. There is no reason to believe that the support would not now be available, and there is no evidence to establish that any medication now taken by the appellant would not be available to him in Turkey.
46. In reply, Ms Lanigan submits there are three issues in the appeal; (i) the credibility of the appellant and his witnesses, (ii) whether the appellant is at risk upon return because of a blood feud, and (iii) whether there is a sufficiency of protection available to the appellant and whether he can internally relocate. She reiterates that the appellant has been let down by his solicitors in the way in which the evidence has been provided. The appellant claims his representatives were made aware of the recent incidents and he has provided documents to his solicitors that have not been referred to or provided to the Tribunal.
47. As far as the appellant’s credibility is concerned, Ms Lanigan acknowledges that adverse credibility findings have been made against the appellant in the past. She submits the factual matrix now relied upon is entirely different and it is not in issue that the appellant has been convicted for the murder of his wife. Ms Lanigan submits the background evidence supports the claim that blood feuds are prevalent in Turkey and can occur within the extended family and continue for decades. The account given by the appellant and his witnesses as to events has also remained consistent. She refers to an article published by Reuters [42] referring to a blood feud with the extended Celebi family in Bilge dating back to a land conflict in the mid 1990’s. In an Article published by the Guardian on 5 May 2009 there is reference to gunmen opening fire at an engagement party in south eastern Turkey during which the prospective bride and groom were killed. The article refers to eight suspects having been detained, most of whom shared the same family name as many of the dead bolstering suggestions that the attack had been driven by an intra-clan vendetta, undermining the claim made by the respondent that a blood feud would not exist amongst the extended family. There is evidence in the ‘Christian Science Monitor’ of a lone peacemaker ending disputes stretching back decades in southeastern Turkey, where blood feuds are still common, even over the smallest incident. The evidence relied upon by the respondent – The Daily Sabah – refers to blood feuds involving traditionally large families. Ms Lanigan submits the appellant’s account is entirely consistent with the background material and entirely plausible.
48. Ms Lanigan submits the witnesses called are all entirely unshaken about the blood feud. The appellant did not shy away from difficult points despite the clear stress he was under. He did his best to assist the Tribunal and was candid. He accepted he had not spoken to his wife’s family and acknowledged that others had tried to stop the blood feud. He candidly accepted the location of the attacks his family have been subjected to is confined to two areas, Turkcayryi and Afsin. He has not sought to bolster his claim. When asked to provide further details, he was able to do so. His account is corroborated by other evidence, including the evidence of the appellant’s brothers RZD, ATD, ALD and a neighbour Mahut Hirli. The appellant’s account of the blood feud is also corroborated by the documents that are relied upon by the appellant. The appellant has provided a translated copy of a document from the Chief Public Prosecution Office that refers to an Offence of ‘wilful murder’ committed on 12 September 2008 in Turkcayari village [197]. The victim is named as Yusuf Dogan and the suspect is Hasan Dogan. The appellant has also provided a translated copy of a letter addressed to the Afsin Public Prosecution Office dated 14 September 2008. The letter refers to the murder of Imdat Bagdinli, Yusuf Dogan and the wounding of Adem Akarsu and GND. The suspect is again named as Hasan Dogan. The appellant has also provided letters from an advocate, Hasan Kaygisiz and from the Village Muhtar Huseyin Dogan, who confirms the existence of a blood feud.
49. Ms Lanigan submits that although the ‘family tree’ [207] that is before the Tribunal only lists one ‘Yusuf Dogan’ (the appellant’s nephew), the consistent evidence of the witnesses is that there are a number of individuals in the family that have the name ‘Yusuf’ and that the reference to a ‘Yusuf Dogan’ who has been granted refugee status in the UK in the appeal of MD (PA/54446/2021), is a different Yusuf Dogan and not the appellant’s nephew who was killed in 2008.
50. Ms Lanigan submits there is evidence of the ongoing blood feud and the risk faced by the appellant. The oral evidence of the appellant is supported by the oral evidence of his brother ALD, who described a recent incident involving his brother ELD and his daughter. The appellant gave evidence that his paternal uncle’s son, BTD was shot at, about four months ago. That is consistent with the evidence of Mahmut Hirli that his father recently told him about an incident when a car was stopped and BTD was attacked. That is evidence that the blood feud continues and the appellant remains at risk despite the passage of time.
51. Ms Lanigan submits that the evidence is that sufficient protection is not being provided. Community leaders have sought to assist to broker peace but the unshaken evidence is that the appellant remains at risk and no protection is being provided to his family by the authorities. The protection available is ineffective. Ms Lanigan submits the informal methods of resolution via the CEM Courts and peacemakers are not recognised by official state structures. They are not elements of the state machinery for protection, and rely upon a willingness to achieve peace. It is, Ms Lanigan submits, evidence of informal measures being required to step in where the state mechanisms do not provide sufficient protection.
52. Ms Lanigan submits internal relocation is not a viable option for the appellant. His deceased wife’s family have engaged in, and demonstrated a willingness to take revenge. Wherever the appellant lives, he will need to register with the Muhtar and he is likely to be identified by that registration or through word of mouth. The appellant lived in Istanbul previously, but that was before the murder of his deceased wife. Ms Lanigan refers to the country guidance decision in IK (Returnees, Records, IFA) [2004] UKIAT 312, which refers, at [112] to [115] to whether an individual should be expected to live without registration with the local Mukhtar. The Tribunal concluded that given the range of basic activities for which a certificate of residence is needed, it would in most normal circumstances, be unduly harsh to expect a person to live without appropriate registration for any material time as a requirement for avoiding persecution. Furthermore, the appellant’s claim that his whereabouts could be established by the payment of a bribe is consistent with the background material. The country information report published by the Australian Government on 16 May 2025 confirms, at [2.36 to 2.37] that despite a strong legal framework, international and domestic observers report that corruption is widespread in Turkey’s public and private sectors and has worsened in recent years. It is also consistent with a paper published by the International Crisis Group which also refers to incidents of corruption in Turkey.
53. Ms Lanigan submits internal relocation would be unduly harsh. The appellant is now a vulnerable individual who relies upon family support in the UK. He would be relocating to Istanbul having been away for a significant period. He is an Alevi Kurd and the respondent’s CPIN; Turkey: Kurds published in July 2025 states, at [10.2.2] that the government considers Kurds as HDP supporters and considers HDP supporters as terrorists. The CPIN also confirms, at [10.2.6] that ‘Erdogan continues his crackdown on his own Kurdish community’ and that his systematic persecution of the Kurds seems to have no bounds. The appellant also has difficulties with his mental health. The report prepared by Helen Keylock, a Forensic Psychologist dated 12 February 2018 that was prepared when the appellant was detained at HMP The Mount, makes an oblique reference to ‘Experience of PTSD’ albeit no diagnosis is set out. There is evidence before the Tribunal of the appellant being prescribed Mirtazapine, which is prescribed for depression and helps improve mood and emotional balance. Ms Lanigan submits that taking all these factors together cumulatively, it would be unduly harsh for the appellant to be expected to internally relocate.
Decision
54. As I set out at the outset, the issue before me is a narrow one. It is whether the appellant will be at risk upon return because of a blood feud. There is a considerable volume of evidence before me. It is entirely impractical for me to burden this decision with a reference to each piece of evidence, written or oral, but for the avoidance of doubt I have had regard to all the evidence before me in reaching my decision. Given the sensitive context of the claims being made by the appellant, I am mindful of the need for the most anxious scrutiny. My findings are reached on the basis of a holistic assessment of the totality of the evidence.
55. I begin by acknowledging that adverse credibility findings have previously been made against the appellant in September 2004. Adjudicator Graeme Peart found that the appellant had “submitted a wholly fraudulent asylum application with no truthful foundation”. It is now well established that if a Court or Tribunal concludes that a witness has lied about one matter, it does not follow that he/she has lied about everything. I accept, as Ms Lanigan submits, that the current claim of a blood feud is based upon a completely separate factual matrix underpinned by the appellant’s conviction for the murder of his wife which is not in dispute. I therefore disregard the previous adverse credibility findings in my consideration of the claim now advanced by the appellant.
56. In reaching my decision, I have had regard to the background material regarding blood feuds in Turkey. I accept, as Ms Lanigan submits that the background evidence supports the claim that blood feuds are prevalent in Turkey and can occur within the extended family and continue for decades. The appellant’s claim is therefore entirely plausible.
57. I recognise that corroboration is not required for a person’s evidence to be accepted. I can therefore accept that there is a real possibility that the appellant’s account is true on the basis of his oral evidence alone. Here, I have also been provided with other evidence that is relied upon by the appellant to support his claim. Insofar as is material, that evidence comprises of:
a. A ‘Non Jurisdiction Order’ [197] dated 7 October 2008 signed by the Public Prosecutor of the Chief Public Prosecution Office regarding the death of Yusuf Dogan (born 06.05.82).
b. A note addressed to the Afsin Public Prosecution Office dated 14 September 2008 [199] regarding the ‘wilful murder’ of Imdat Bagdinli and Yusuf Dogan and the ‘wounding’ of Adem Akarsu and GND on 12 September 2008. The suspect is named as Hasan Dogan.
c. An undated statement of RZD [187]
d. A letter from Hasan Kaygisiz who claims to be an Advocate in Turkey dated 14 February 2011 [203]. He provides an opinion as to what is likely to happen to the appellant on return to Turkey at the request of the appellant’s relatives in Turkey. The opinion is repeated in a further letter from him dated 17 July 2013 [301].
e. A letter from Hasan Kaygisiz [297] that is signed off by Hasan Kaygisz in the following way: “I hereby confirm the circumstances and the fact that this letter has been delivered to me by my client [RZD] in order for it to be dispatched to [the appellant] 12.11.13..”
f. A translated ‘statement’ from Huseyin Dogan, who is described as the ‘Turkcayiri Village Governor’[195], that appears to be dated 21 February 2011, certified as having been translated on 25 November 2021.
g. A translated ‘statement’ from Huseyin Dogan, who is described as the village governor of Afsin District, Kahramanmaras Province [123]. The statement appears to be dated 27 November 2013.
h. A translated ‘statement’ from Huseyin Dogan, who is described as the village Mayor at Afsin District, Kahramanmaras Province [295]. The statement appears to be undated but the translation is certified as having been undertaken on 31 January 2014.
The Blood Feud
58. I attach very little weight to the witness statements made by those that have not appeared before the Tribunal to give evidence and submitted to cross-examination. Their witness statements are in very vague terms. For the reasons that follow, and having carefully considered all the evidence in the round, I find the appellant to be an unimpressive and unreliable witness. Much of the written evidence before me is very vague. The evidence relied upon by the appellant and the witnesses that he called to give oral evidence before me is inconsistent and I was left in no doubt that the appellant, ALD and Mahmut Hirli, are not witnesses of truth and I find that they have sought to exaggerate their evidence to the Tribunal concerning the risk arising from a blood feud.
59. Taking matters chronologically, I begin with the claims concerning events said to have occurred in 2005 and 2008. There is a paucity of evidence before me regarding any attacks in 2005 and the evidence before me regarding the attack in September 2008 is vague and in material respects, inconsistent as to the number of individuals attacked and killed.
60. In his first witness statement dated 6 September 2016 [290] the appellant claims that his deceased wife's family in Turkey seek to revenge her killing through a blood feud. He provided no further information. In his second witness statement dated 19 October 2020 [37] the appellant again claimed that he is in danger from his deceased wife's family who want revenge against him and have vowed to kill him. The appellant claims (paragraph 5) that his brother RZD was attacked and assaulted in Afsin in 2005.
61. In a letter provided by RZD dated 12 November 2013 via Hasan Kaygisiz, [297], RZD refers to the situation being “the same as it was in the 12th month of 2005” without elaboration. He makes no reference to any attack in 2008. In his undated witness statement, RZD refers to the family being involved in a blood feud in Turkey, but he makes no reference and does not provide any information about an occasion in 2005 when he was attacked or assaulted.
62. As far as the attack in September 2008 is concerned, on one version of events, three individuals were attacked, two of whom were killed:
a. In his witness statement dated 19 October 2020 [37] the appellant claimed that his relatives, Yusuf Dogan, Imdat Bagdanli and GND were attacked in 2008 and Yusuf and Imdat were killed. That account, using exactly the same words, is set out in paragraph [2] of the witness statement of ALD dated 8 April 2021. Neither the appellant nor his brother ALD provide any information about that incident. It is however clear that both the appellant and ALD refer to three people being attacked, two of whom were killed. They are Yusuf Dogan and Imdat Bagdanli. I accept that neither the appellant nor ALD were in Turkey at the time and so they will not have witnessed the incident. However neither of them provide any information about the events leading to the deaths of Yusuf Dogan and Imdat Bagdanli, and the wounding of GND.
b. Hasan Kaygisz, the Advocate in Turkey, who is relied upon by the appellant sets out in his letter dated 17 July 2013 [301] an opinion as to what is likely to happen to the appellant if he returns to Turkey. He states that the appellant’s deceased wife’s family have deep vengeful feelings towards the appellant. He refers to the “armed attack” in Turkcayin in 2008 and states Yusuf Dogan and Imdat Bagdanli were killed and the appellant’s niece GND was wounded in the head. Hasan Kaygisz appears to rely entirely upon what he has been told by others. He has been told that two individuals were killed and one was injured.
63. Another version of the attack in 2008 is that four individuals were attacked, two of whom were killed and two of whom were injured:
a. In his witness statement dated 7 July 2026, RZD refers to the 12 September 2008 attack as being the most serious incident. RZD claims the attack happened outside his front door when they were with two people who had come to buy sheep from him. Without any further elaboration, he states:
“…Mr relative Yusuf, who was my sister's son was shot and killed as was Imdat Bagdanli, one of the people that had come to buy sheep from me. The other person and my daughter, [GND], were injured. I was not injured in this incident. We were attacked by two relatives of [the appellant’s] wife.”
b. The appellant relies upon a note addressed to the Afsin Public Prosecution Office dated 14 September 2008 [199] regarding the ‘wilful murder’ of Imdat Bagdinli and Yusuf Dogan and the ‘wounding’ of Adem Akarsu and GND. There is reference in the note to an ‘automatic hunting rifle’ used in the incident. The note refers to four individuals being attacked, two of whom were killed.
64. A further version of the attack in 2008 is that four individuals were attacked, three of whom were killed and one of whom was injured
a. In his oral evidence before me, the appellant claimed that the attack on his relatives, in 2008 was one in which three people were murdered and his niece, GND was injured.
b. In the evidence before me there is a list of family members that is relied upon by the appellant [207]. In his oral evidence before me, the appellant said that that document is, he thinks, in his brother’s handwriting. In his oral evidence before me, ALD said that he believes that document was prepared by his brother RZD. The document sets out the name of various family members and their relationship to the appellant. As far as the attack in September 2008 is concerned, the document states:
“Yusuf Dogan is my nephew from my sister ….. He was shot and killed. Imdat Bagdanli was a visitor from another village who happened to be there and was killed during the shooting that was taken to my family. GND is my niece who is my brother’s daughter (RZD) who also took a gunshot wound to the head during the shooting. Adem Akarsu was a visitor from another village who was also shot and killed during the shooting against my family”.
That document states that there were three people that were shot and killed during the incident, namely Yusuf Dogan, Imdat Bagdanli and Adem Akarsu. It is not entirely clear whether the manuscript list of family members was prepared by RZD, as ALD believes, or another of the appellant’s brothers, but what is clear is that the document refers to three individuals having been killed during the attack in 2008 and GND having suffered a gunshot wound.
65. Mahmut Hirli has made two witness statement. The first is dated 23 November 2021 and the second is dated 7 July 2026. He is from the same village as the appellant and lived in Turkey until he left in June 2020. He claims to have heard about the ‘blood feud between the two families and he refers to the death of Yusuf Dogan and Imdat Bagdalni. He claims they were killed by members of the appellant’s wife’s family but provides no further information. He does not refer to anyone else having been killed or injured during that incident.
66. In his oral evidence before me, Mahmut Hirli was asked about his claim that he had witnessed Yusuf Dogan, who he claims was the appellant’s deceased wife’s brother, attack ELD who is the appellant’s younger brother. He claimed that the attack had taken place in the village in Turkey. In re-examination Mr Hirli claimed that the incident that he is referring to when Yusuf attacked ELD, was to his recollection, an incident when Yusuf came to the door and he attacked and punched ELD. The evidence of Mahmut Hirli is that it was the appellant’s younger brother EDL that was attacked ‘at the door. RZD refers in his witness statement dated 7 July 2026, to the 12 September 2008 attack as having occurred outside his front door. He makes no reference to EDL having been present or indeed attacked. It is not at all clear whether Mr Hirli is referring to the occasion when it is claimed by others that Yusuf Dogan was killed in September 2008. If he is not, it is striking that he appears to have no knowledge of two (or three) people having been killed. If it is the same incident, his evidence is at odds with others wo make no reference to ELD having been present or attacked by the appellant’s deceased wife’s brother.
67. The ‘Non Jurisdiction Order’ [197] signed by the Public Prosecutor of the Chief Public Prosecution Office regarding the death of Yusuf Dogan states that he was injured with a hunting rifle by Hasan Dogan on 12 September 2008 and passed away while he was being treated in Hospital on 13 September 2008. The Prosecution Office states that due to the location it has “no competence” and the files were sent to the Afsin Prosecution Office. There is no reference in that document to anyone else (other than Yusuf Dogan) having been killed or attacked.
68. Standing back and considering the evidence before me in the round and holistically, it is my judgment incredible that neither the appellant, his brothers nor Mr Hirli are able to give a reliable and consistent account of the names and number of individuals that were killed during the attack in September 2008. The evidence is in some respects also internally inconsistent with the documents relied upon by the appellant.
69. It would have been obvious whether one, two or three people were killed. Despite the fact that the appellant and ALD were not in Turkey at the time, it is not credible that they would not have been told of the detail of the incident and in particular, who had been killed or injured. The account given of the incident is very vague and lacks any detail. I was left in no doubt that the appellant and his wider family, including his brothers, are familiar with the procedure for making a claim for international protection and indeed the appeals process. It is no answer to simply say that the claim was left in the hands of the appellant’s representatives. That may be so, but that would not prevent the evidence provided, even if limited, from being internally consistent. I reject the appellant’s claim that his family had been targeted in 2005 and 2008 to avenge the killing of his deceased wife through a blood feud.
70. I then turn to the events postdating 2008. I reject the written evidence of RZD that he was targeted in 2012, 2018 and 2019 by the family of the appellant’s deceased wife. In his undated witness statement and his witness statement dated 7 July 2026, RZD claims that there have been several other incidents where he was shot at while driving to Afsin. He refers to an incident in “2012” when he claims he was “attacked from the back by two of the [appellant’s deceased wife’s] brother.”. He claims they said to him that they wanted to kill the appellant but as he was not there, they would deal with him instead. He states the police came and stopped them attacking him. RZD has provided information as set out in the letter from Hasan Kaygisiz [297]. He set out, on 12 November 2013, what he describes to be the ‘latest situation’. He states that on 12 April 21012 the appellant’s deceased wife’s brothers Ayhan and Yusuf and one of ‘their friends’ attacked him in Afsin. He claims that “.. Whatever they grabbed hold of, they smashed them on my head..”. He claimed that people around at the time and the police saved him from death. In his written evidence he also refers to an attack in 2018 in the early morning, in the garden’. He states “the last time I was attacked was in 2019.”. He claims that attack occurred in Afsin City Centre when he was attacked from behind. He claims he tried to run, but was caught and beaten. The evidence before me regarding those events is vague and lacks any detail. Understandably, neither the appellant not his brother ALD could give evidence regarding those incidents.
71. ALD has signed three witness statement dated 8 April 2021, 19 July 2022, and 7 July 2026. In all three of the statements he refers to RZD having been attacked and assaulted in Afsin in 2005 and to the attack that is said to have occurred in September 2008. He makes no reference to any attacks on his brother RZD in 2018 and 2019, or indeed of the family having been targeted since.
72. Finally, as I have said, Mahmut Hirli has made two witness statements, the most recent of which is dated 7 July 2026. Neither RZD, ALD nor Mahmut Hirli refer to the appellant’s family in Turkey being targeted recently. ALD and Mahmut Hirli claimed in their oral evidence that there have been recent incidents that they provided details of to the appellant’s solicitors via an interpreter, that for some unexplained reason has not been referred to in the written statements that they signed.
73. I reject the appellant’s claim that his brother, ELD was recently sent a text asking him when the appellant would be returning. The appellant accepts that his brother has not made a statement. He claimed ELD had sent him a message saying that he was receiving threats. The appellant has not provided a copy the message he received.
74. I have due regard to the fact that neither the appellant nor the two witnesses who gave oral evidence before me, were in Turkey earlier this year when the most recent incidents are said to have occurred. They rely upon information provided to them by others. Nevertheless, it is my judgment telling that neither ALD, RZD nor Mr Hirli make any reference to the recent events in their written statements, particularly when the evidence of ALD is that he had prepared his statement himself in Turkish and it was translated into English before he signed it.
75. I reject the oral evidence of the witnesses regarding the claim that the appellant’s family in Turkey continue to be targeted because on an on-going blood feud. RZD, ALD and Mahmut Hirli have signed witness statements dated 7 July 2026, which on any view post-date the recent events they refer to and the appellant now relies upon. I reject the claim made that the information provided to the appellant’s representatives regarding the recent incidents, which they claim was communicated via an interpreter, was simply left out by the appellant’s representatives. Even if it had not been included in the witness statements presented to them to be signed, I was left in no doubt that the appellant and his wider family, including brother’s, and Mahmut Hirli are familiar with the procedure for making a claim for international protection and indeed the appeals process. The statements were translated to them in a language that they understood before they were signed and they signed a declaration that the facts stated in the statement are true. They each claim the appellant’s deceased wife’s family are intent on finding the appellant and it is not credible that they would not have referred to recent events if any had truly occurred. They would have been aware of the omission when the statements were read back to them and I was left in no doubt that they would have been anxious to ensure relevant evidence was set out.
76. The appellant claims he was told by his brother RZD that his paternal uncle’s son, BTD was shot about four or five months ago. Riaz Dogan does not refer to any such incident in his witness statement dated 7 July 2026. If, as the appellant claims, the incident occurred in or about May 2026, it is curious that RZD refers to historical incidents that occurred between 2008 and 2019 but fails to refer to an incident which would have been very clearly in his mind, despite claiming that the blood feud continues.
77. In his oral evidence, ALD claimed that his brother ELD had told him that when he was taking his daughter to school, the appellant’s deceased wife’s family put a huge rock in front of the car to stop the car. His brother changed direction and tried to go a different way. There were people waiting with guns. His brother managed to run away and went to the Gendarme. There is no reference in the evidence of ALD to BTD having been present let alone being shot or shot at.
78. For his part, Mahmut Hirli refers to the most recent he has been told of by his father to be an attack on BTD. Although he initially referred to an attack and shooting, in the end his evidence was that although there were some guns involved, nobody was shot. He said there were people aiming guns and they “let them off the car”. I asked who, and Mr Hirli said that ELD was definitely there, but he does not know who else was in the car. The account said to have been provided by Mr Hirli’s father to Mr Hirli is broadly consistent with what the appellant claims he has been told by RZD but is not consistent with the account provided by ELD to his brother ALD. Although both Mr Hirli and the appellant refer to the presence of BTD, one claims he was shot and the other claims no-one was shot.
79. Huseying Dogan simply states the appellant will be “the subject of some great incidents due to the fact that he has killed [his deceased wife], and that no reconciliation has been reached between the parties.
80. I am left in no doubt that the evidence provided to me regarding recent events is wholly unreliable and is evidence upon which I can attach very little weight when considering whether the appellant is at risk upon return to Tukey because of an ongoing blood feud. Again, standing back and considering the evidence before me in the round and holistically, I reject the appellant’s claim that his family have been targeted since 2008 and recently, earlier in 2026, to avenge the killing of his deceased wife through a blood feud.
81. Having rejected the appellant’s claim that he will be at risk upon return by reason of an on-going blood feud, the questions of sufficiency of protection and internal relation do not arise. For the avoidance of any doubt, I am in any event satisfied that if the appellant is of any interest to his former wife’s family at all, there is a sufficiency of protection available to him and that it would not be unduly harsh for him to live elsewhere in Turkey for reasons that I can set out in brief terms.
82. Hasan Kaygisz, the Advocate in Turkey, who is relied upon by the appellant sets out in his letter dated 17 July 2013 [301] an opinion as to what is likely to happen to the appellant if he returns to Turkey. He states that the appellant’s deceased wife’s family have deep vengeful feelings towards the appellant. He states that if the appellant returns to Turkey he will be pursued wherever he goes “..as has been experienced in such events before, and it is likely that [the appellant] will encounter some undesirable situations..”. He states that it would be better for the appellant if he does not return to Turkey. His opinion is clearly based upon information that has been provided to him by the appellant's family. I have rejected the core of the appellant’s account for the reasons set out above. In any event, Mr Kaygisz does not refer to any source information and the letter discloses no basis upon which he has either the expertise or experience to offer a credible opinion to which any proper weight can be attached.
Sufficiency of Protection
83. I have rejected the core of the appellant’s account. However, on any view, the appellant does not claim to be at risk upon return to Turkey because of ‘state actors’. Here, the appellant relies upon the evidence of Huseyin Dogan, who is described as the village governor or Muhtar of Afsin District, Kahramanmaras Province. He is the maternal uncle of the appellant’s deceased wife, and on the appellant’s account, has intervened and sought to make peace between the families. The appellant has the support of his own family and indeed influential members of his deceased wife’s family.
84. Although I have rejected the claims made by the appellant, on his own case, on those occasions when members of his family in Turkey have had to seek the assistance of the authorities, the authorities have been prepared to assist as far as they can. Although there is background material that suggests some Kurds may be reluctant to report incidents due to a low level of trust in the police, that is not the same as the state’s unwillingness to provide protection. The appellant’s family have turned to the authorities for protection and it has been forthcoming. I find that the Turkish authorities, even on the appellant’s case, have provided a reasonable level of protection to the appellant’s family within the meaning outlined in Horvath v SSHD [2000] UKHL 37. That same protection will be available to the appellant. A system of protection cannot and does not need to guarantee a person’s safety.
Internal Relocation
85. Finally, on the appellant’s own account, the attacks on his family have occurred in Turkcayryi and in Afsin. His deceased wife’s family live in Afsin. The distance between the two is about 35 to 40km. The appellant does not claim that his deceased wife’s family have reach or influence, outside of their home area. Rather, he claims that he could be found by payment of a bribe. On the findings I have made, I do not accept that the appellant’s deceased wife’s family have the ability to exert influence away from their home area and neither do they have any motive to track the appellant down. There are Kurdish communities throughout Turkey and Turkish citizens are free to move throughout the country.
86. The respondent’s CPIN, July 2025, confirms that in an article updated in June 2024, MRGI reported that ‘The majority of Turkish Kurds are Sunni Muslims, while a significant number are Alevi’s.’. Kurds are the largest ethnic and linguistic minority in Turkey. There is a large Kurdish population in Istanbul. The CPIN records: ‘The Director of a Turkish organisation in the UK added that “Approximately 4 million Kurds live in Istanbul, which is more than the number in Ankara.” Furthermore, the CPIN confirms that Kurdish Alevi’s are more likely to identify primarily as Alevi, and, while Alevi’s are widely distributed across Turkey, they are concentrated in central and inner-eastern Anatolia, Istanbul and other major cities.
87. The appellant previously lived in Istanbul in 2000 with his maternal aunt. I reject the appellant’s claim that he is not sure where his maternal aunt is, or whether she is still alive. It was clear to me that the evidence of the appellant and his witnesses was that the appellant hails from a large extended, and close knit family. Having previously lived with his maternal aunt in Istanbul, I do not accept that the appellant would not, despite the passage of time, have been curious about the whereabouts of his maternal aunt and her wellbeing. The evidence of the appellant was, I find, an attempt by him to distance himself from relatives elsewhere in Turkey. I find that the appellant could turn to his maternal aunt in Istanbul for support, particularly in the short term. She has assisted the appellant in the past, and there is no reason to suggest that she would not do so in the future, if the appellant felt unable to return to his home area.
88. Any risk will be at its highest in the appellant’s home area. I accept that registration is required with the local Mukhtar when moving to a new area. Registration is in legal terms compulsory. On registration a person will receive a certificate of residence which allows the individual to do a wide range of things in Turkey that engage the state and in some respects the private sector, associated with their day to day living. In the country guidance decision IK (Returnees, Records, IAF), the Upper Tribunal noted that there is evidence that a large number of people in Turkey do not in fact register with their local Mukhtar, at least for a time. The Upper Tribunal concluded that given the range of basic activities for which a certificate of residence is needed, it would in most normal circumstances be unduly harsh to expect a person to live without appropriate registration for any material time as a requirement for avoiding persecution. On the findings I have made, the family of the appellant’s deceased wife do not have any reach or influence outside of their home area in and around Afsin and Turkcayryi. In fact influential members of her family have supported the appellant’s appeal and clearly do not wish him to come to any harm. Information provided by the appellant on registration would not be readily available to the family of the appellant’s deceased wife and while corruption may be widespread, I do not accept that an official would wish to transfer or provide information on payment of a bribe that could potentially lead to their prosecution.
89. Despite any vulnerability, the appellant has not established that any on-going treatment that he requires will not be available to him in, for example, Istanbul. Although he has been away for a significant period, the appellant was born in Turkey and spent his formative years there. He is likely still to be familiar with many of the cultures and practices. He speaks Turkish, has at least some experience of work and skills that he will be able to utilise. He has lived there previously and despite the passage of time, we would be able to return there with the support of his family. I do not accept that internal relocation would be unduly harsh in all the circumstances.
90. It follows that I reject the appellant’s claim that he will be at risk upon return because of a blood feud and I dismiss his appeal.
Notice of Decision
91. The appeal is dismissed.
V. Mandalia
Upper Tribunal Judge Mandalia
Judge of the Upper Tribunal
Immigration and Asylum Chamber
22 October 2026