UI-2025-003529
- Case title:
- Appellant name:
- Status of case: Unreported
- Hearing date:
- Promulgation date:
- Publication date:
- Last updated on:
- Country:
- Judges:
The decision
IN THE UPPER TRIBUNAL
IMMIGRATION AND ASYLUM CHAMBER Case No: UI-2025-003529
First-tier Tribunal No: PA/51485/2024
LP/13253/2024
THE IMMIGRATION ACTS
Decision & Reasons Issued:
2nd November 2026
Before
DEPUTY UPPER TRIBUNAL JUDGE MCCARTHY
Between
RAM
(ANONYMITY ORDER MADE)
Appellant
and
SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT
Respondent
Representation:
For the Appellant: Mr N Nadeem
For the Respondent: Mrs R Arif
Heard at Birmingham Civil Justice Centre on 20 October 2026
Order Regarding Anonymity
Pursuant to rule 14 of the Tribunal Procedure (Upper Tribunal) Rules 2008, the appellant is granted anonymity.
No-one shall publish or reveal any information, including the name or address of the appellant, likely to lead members of the public to identify the appellant. Failure to comply with this order could amount to a contempt of court.
DECISION AND REASONS
1. There is no dispute over the appellant’s identity. He is a national of Iraq of Kurdish ethnicity. He was born on 17 April 2001. When he claimed asylum, he was 20 years 4 months old. By the time the appeal came before me for the decision to be remade in the Upper Tribunal, he was 25 years and 6 months old.
2. On 21 January 2026, Deputy Upper Tribunal Judge Alis found that the First-tier Tribunal’s (FtT) decision and reasons issued on 16 June 2025, contains legal error. Judge Alis preserved the FtT Judge’s findings dismissing the appellant’s claim on all matters other than whether he could be re-documented. Judge Alis retained the appeal to the Upper Tribunal, and it was transferred to me to remake the decision.
Procedural matters
3. I record the following procedural matters dealt with during the hearing.
a. Neither party sought to lift the anonymity order made by Judge Alis. Given the issues in the appeal, I maintain the anonymity order for the reasons previously given.
b. There were no communication difficulties between the Kurdish Sorani interpreter and the appellant. Although the appellant said he was fluent in English, I explained that it was in the interests of justice that he gives his evidence through the interpreter to ensure there are no misunderstandings, which might otherwise arise because of nerves or other issues relating to the nature of the proceedings. I agreed that there was no need for the interpreter to interpret other conversations in the hearing as I acknowledged the appellant would be able to follow those or would be able to ask his legal representative for clarification after the hearing.
c. The parties rely on the evidence in the 101-page “remaking hearing bundle” and the Home Office County Bulletin, Iraq: Internal relocation, civil documentation and returns (update following setting aside of County Guidance) (July 2026, Ref: IRQ-002-07-26). The parties confirmed the relevant case law is SMO & KSP (Civil status documentation; article 15) Iraq CG [2022] UKUT 00110 (IAC), a copy of which was in the bundle.
d. During oral evidence, the appellant wanted to admit three documents, being two photographs of him outside the Iraqi Embassy in London, and a document setting out mandatory application requirements for an electronic Iraqi passport and a ticket number (703) showing attendance at the Embassy at 12.25 pm on 06 May 2026. After the documents had been examined by Mr Nadeem, Mrs Arif, and me, Mrs Arif did not object to the documents being admitted, although queried why they were not provided earlier. I decided to admit them, leaving Mrs Arif’s query to submissions.
Matters no longer in dispute
4. The following matters were clarified and/or conceded during the hearing.
a. In response to a question from Mr Nadeem, Mrs Arif confirmed that the SSHD is proposing to return the appellant via either Sulaymaniyah or Erbil, and that it was most likely to be Erbil because that is where he is from.
b. Mrs Arif confirmed that issues relating to the appellant’s practical position on return (in terms of accommodation, employment, and family support) depended on his ability to be redocumented. If he could not be redocumented, then article 3 of the human rights convention would be engaged, as explained in SMO. Mr Nadeem agreed.
c. Mrs Arif accepted that the appellant attended the Iraqi Embassy in London on 6 May 2026 and enquired about obtaining Iraqi documents.
d. Mrs Arif confirmed the SSHD accepts that the appellant does not have a CSID card with him in the UK.
Appellant’s evidence
5. The appellant adopted his witness statement of 10 February 2026. He admits that a CSID was issued for him when he was a child, that he could only recall seeing it on two occasions, that is was kept by his parents and was always under their control, and that he never had reason to use the document. The appellant also said that he does not know the Civil Status Affairs office where he was registered, and did not know his family book number, volume or page reference.
6. The appellant said he last had direct contact with his family when he was in Iraq and has been out of contact with them since he left. He spoke to a family friend named Mamand when in France (the jungle). Mamand lived in a neighbouring village and happened to contact another man who was in the jungle at the same time. That man brought his phone to me, and we were able to speak. Mamand told me that the PKK were sill looking for him and had gone to the family home asking about his whereabouts. The appellant said that he did not have any means of contacting his family in Iraq and that it was not safe to ask others to approach them for him because of the interest shown in him by the authorities.
7. The appellant raised several concerns about being redocumented. He said that presenting an expired CSID with a childhood photograph would place him at real risk as he would be suspected of impersonation, identity fraud, or using false documents. He thought he would be detained or ill-treated as a result. He commented that CSID cards are no longer issued and he would need to attend an office in person to be issued with an INID. The appellant believes that without an INID he would be at risk of detention or ill-treatment in Iraq.
8. In oral evidence, the appellant said that in Iraq he had lived with his parents, two sisters, one brother, and an uncle and aunt. He said he had not spoken to any of them since he left. The appellant said that in his home area they had never had to use ID documents as there were very few residences.
9. The appellant described his conversation with Mamand. He explained that he did not know the man who gave him the phone and that the call lasted about two minutes. After the call, the man who had the phone left immediately and the appellant was unable to find him. He was unable to get Mamand’s contact details as the call had been so quick and the man had left immediately. The conversation with Mamand was brief. He said Mamand started the conversation, checked he was alive, after which the appellant asked about his family. Mamand said that the house had been raided on many occasions by PKK and that they were looking for the appellant. That was all as the call was disconnected.
10. The appellant said he had tried other ways to contact his family in Iraq. When he had been on demonstrations, he had asked people if they could chase things up for him. He would give them his name, the name of his village, and the names of his family. None of his enquiries had been successful. The appellant had not sought to trace his family through any international organisation, such as the Red Cross. He said he had discussed this with his lawyers but as his family home was in a remote area, it was not easy to get anyone to trace them. Because of their isolation, the appellant said his family did not have access to the internet so trying to contact them through social media was not possible.
Submissions
For the Respondent
11. Mrs Arif reminded me of the preserved findings and that the only issue for me to decide is about whether the appellant would face torture, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment contrary to article 3 of the human rights convention. This requires an assessment of whether he would be able to obtain a CSID or an INID. The burden of proof lies on the appellant, and the standard of proof is the lower standard, often described as a real possibility.
12. Mrs Arif said that the appellant’s account about not being able to be redocumented is not credible. She points to the previous adverse credibility findings and submits that his statement and oral evidence should not be given any weight as they are mere assertions. He has not made any meaningful attempts to contact his family.
13. Mrs Arif argues that the appellant relies on speculation about not being able to contact his family or trace his details. The fact the appellant knows his own identity details, his father’s name and his home village point to him being able to have sufficient information to trace his details. His visit to the Iraqi Embassy does not identify that he cannot be documented, only what he would need to obtain documents.
14. Overall, according to Mrs Arif, the appellant has failed to show there is a real possibility that he could not be redocumented and has not discharged the burden on him. As a result, there is no real risk of article 3 being breached.
For the Appellant
15. Mr Nadeem relied on the ASA skeleton argument and that the two factual questions for me to answer are whether the appellant can access a replacement CSID card and return to Iraq, and whether the appellant meets the requirements of paragraph 276ADE(1)(vi) of the Immigration Rules. Mr Nadeem said the first issue was not about past credibility but about the mechanics of obtaining Iraqi documents.
16. Mr Nadeem on the following four point: the appellant has no usable Iraqi document, he cannot obtain a replacement through the embassy in London, he has no family support, and he will be unable to access a CSA office in Iraq. He derives the first point from the respondent’s acceptance that the appellant has no document with him in the UK. The second point is established by SMO and the appellant’s evidence when he attended the embassy. Although the Country Bulletin points to the ability of the embassy in London being able to issue replacement documents, it is ambivalent on whether that can be done where no original or copy is provided. The third point is drawn from the appellant’s consistent evidence that he is not in contact with his family and has no means to contact them. The final issue arises from the country information about travel in the IKR.
17. Overall, according to Mr Nadeem, the appellant has discharged the burden on him as the above points arise notwithstanding the past adverse credibility findings. As a result, the appellant faces a real risk of serious harm contrary to article 3 of the human rights convention.
Findings
18. I agree with Mr Nadeem as far as he says that the previous adverse credibility findings were derived from other parts of the appellant’s accounts and not from his account of not having contact with his family or access to his identity document. I keep in mind that an account can lack credibility on some issues but may be reliable on others. Although an adverse credibility finding may make me careful when looking at other evidence, it does not automatically lead me to find everything the appellant says to lack truth.
19. I have considered the evidence provided for and given at the remaking hearing. As I indicated at the end of the hearing, I reserved my decision because I would need to review the evidence. Having had time to do so, I realise I have difficulty reconciling two parts of the appellant’s evidence. In his witness statement, the appellant said he was unable to ask other people to help him locate his family in Iraq because its was not safe to do so. When cross-examined about his statement, he gave a different account and said that he had sought the help of others, namely people he met at demonstrations in the UK. He gave them his own details and those of his family and asked them if they could get any information.
20. Such a change in account causes me to doubt the reliability of the appellant’s evidence about not having contact with his family. I find this conflict in the evidence undermines the consistency the appellant has given about not being in contact with his family and not being able to regain contact because both accounts cannot be true. Either he has avoided asking for others to help, or he has asked them to help find his family.
21. I conclude that the appellant has failed to establish to the lower standard of proof that he is not in contact with his family or that he is unable to contact his family. The appellant has never said that his family would not assist him if he was in contact with them. This means his case on redocumentation difficulties fails because it is reasonable to infer that he would be able to get the necessary information to be redocumented through the Iraqi Embassy in London. As a result, I find against the appellant’s claim that he would face torture, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment contrary to article 3 of the human rights convention.
Notice of Decision
I remake the decision.
The appeal is dismissed.
Judge John McCarthy
Deputy Judge of the Upper Tribunal
Immigration and Asylum Chamber