UI-2026-000099
- Case title:
- Appellant name:
- Status of case: Unreported
- Hearing date:
- Promulgation date:
- Publication date:
- Last updated on:
- Country:
- Judges:
The decision
IN THE UPPER TRIBUNAL
IMMIGRATION AND ASYLUM CHAMBER Case No: UI-2026-000099
First-tier Tribunal: PA/56870/2026
THE IMMIGRATION ACTS
Decision & Reasons Issued:
2nd November 2026
Before
UPPER TRIBUNAL JUDGE LANDES
DEPUTY UPPER TRIBUNAL JUDGE J F W PHILLIPS
Between
A G
(Anonymity decision made)
Appellant
and
SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT
Respondent
Representation:
For the Appellant: Mr J Collins, Counsel instructed by Montague Solicitors
For the Respondent: Mrs R Arif, Senior Home Office Presenting Officer
Heard at Cardiff Civil Justice Centre on 15 September 2026
DECISION AND REASONS
1. The Appellant appeals against the decision of the First-tier Tribunal dated 23 October 2025 dismissing his appeal against the Respondent’s decision refusing his protection and human rights claim. Permission to appeal was granted on 8 January 2026. On 26 June 2026 Deputy Chamber President Plimmer found error of law in the decision of the First-tier Tribunal and set that decision aside and ordered that it be remade in the Upper Tribunal.
Background
2. The Appellant a citizen of Türkiye of Kurdish ethnicity claimed, in summary, that he was at risk on return to Türkiye due to his association with the Gulen movement. He worked as manager at a factory associated with the Gulen movement, his wages were paid through Asya Bank, which is also associated with the Gulenists, and his uncle was a member of the Gulen movement. As a result, he had been detained and tortured as the Turkish authorities suspected that he was part of the Gulenist movement.
The appeal to the First-tier Tribunal
3. The Appellant’s appeal against the Respondent’s decision was heard by First-tier Tribunal Judge Hayball in an oral hearing on 23 October 2025. The Judge was not satisfied that the Appellant’s factual account of events in Türkiye was true or that he had established that he feared persecution for the convention reason of real or imputed political opinion and dismissed his appeal.
The appeal to the Upper Tribunal
4. First-tier Tribunal Judge Adio granted permission to appeal to the Upper Tribunal on 8 January 2026 on two grounds. Firstly, that the First-tier Tribunal had failed to have regard to country guidance when assessing prospective risk in Türkiye and secondly that the First-tier Tribunal had made an irrational finding regarding the timing of the Appellant’s departure from Türkiye.
5. In a decision dated 26 June 2026 Deputy Chamber President Plimmer found that the second of these grounds revealed no error of law. However, DCP Plimmer found that the Judge had materially erred in law by failing to assess the prospective risk on a return to Türkiye in the light of the Appellant’s accepted background. The matter was retained in the Upper Tribunal for factual findings to be made on this limited issue.
The hearing
6. No oral evidence was called and the hearing proceeded on submissions only.
7. Mr Collins, referring to the skeleton argument, said that the Appellant was at risk on the accepted facts. The Turkish government is increasingly authoritarian and notwithstanding the passage of time since the failed coup there is adverse interest in anyone suspected of involvement with the Gulen movement. The Appellant worked in a factory linked to Gulen, his wages were paid through Asya Bank which is associated with Gulen, and his paternal uncle was a member of Gulen. It is clear that on the accepted facts he would be questioned at the airport. Mr Collins referred to the phases identified in IK (Returnees - Records - IFA) Turkey [2004] UKIAT 00312. We were referred to the “Gulen bundle” uploaded on the Appellant’s behalf. This commences with the August 2025 CPIN “Turkey Gulenists” and continues with more recent information. Thousands of people have been detained on suspicion of links to the Gulen movement. Merely being an account holder with Asya Bank is a risk factor. The issue is questioning at the airport which will be inevitable for the Appellant returning without a passport on a one-way travel document. Mr Collins referred us to a multitude of specific paragraphs from the CPIN and other material in the “Gulen bundle” all from the last 12 months or so.
8. Ms Arif acknowledged that there was continued scrutiny of suspected Gulenists by the Turkish authorities but said that the CPIN does not show that everyone with a history is at risk. The Appellant relies on general risk. There is no evidential basis to conclude that the Turkish authorities will be unable to establish his identity. Questioning at the airport is likely to be routine and directed to establishing his identity. It is not established that he has links to the Gulen movement, his case depends upon assumption. Being asked questions at the airport police station is not equivalent to being interrogated by the anti-terror police. Having an Asya bank account alone does not put him at risk, the CPIN only identifies this as a possible risk factor. The absence of historical state interest substantially undermined the contention that he would be at risk now. He would not be of sufficient interest. His individual profile does not demonstrate risk.
Decision
9. We have very carefully considered all the documents submitted by both parties and in particular the very detailed and helpful submissions of both representatives. In remaking the decision of the First-tier Tribunal the issue for us to resolve is a straightforward one. The First-tier Tribunal found that the Appellant had not been detained and tortured by the Turkish authorities and had not come to adverse attention. However certain facts of the Appellant’s claim were accepted, and the question is whether on these accepted facts the Appellant would be at risk on return.
10. The accepted facts have been highlighted very clearly in Mr Collins submissions and were not challenged by Ms Arif. The Appellant is Kurdish from Gaziantep in Eastern Türkiye. His paternal uncle is a member of the Gulen movement. The Appellant was the general manager of a factory linked to the Gulen movement. His wages were paid into Asya Bank where he held an account. Asya Bank is associated with the Gulen movement.
11. To these accepted facts must be added the means of the Appellant’s return to Türkiye. He does not have, and has never held, a passport. He will be returned on a one-way travel document issued by the UK government. This will be the document that he has to present on his arrival at immigration control in Türkiye.
12. Taking the nature of his arrival in Türkiye first we must find that it is reasonably likely that he will be questioned upon return. Indeed, we would go so far as to say that it is very likely indeed. Ms Arif accepted in her submissions that he would be questioned but asserted that the questioning is likely to be routine, simply to establish identity and the Appellant had said in asylum interview that he had his Turkish ID card. We cannot agree with this assertion. The Turkish authorities will be well aware that a Turkish national returning without his own passport and with a UK issued travel document is not only likely to have left Türkiye irregularly but also given the method of return to have claimed asylum in the United Kingdom. It must also be likely that he will be asked the basis of his claim, indeed [84] of IK indicates that the questioning at the airport police station would involve the reason for the asylum application A true answer is likely to lead to further questioning. This is where the accepted facts must be likely to come into play.
13. The authority of IK (Returnees – records – IFA) Turkey, as accepted by Mr Collins in submissions is old. But it remains good guidance and indeed events in Türkiye since the publication of IK do not suggest that the situation for those potentially facing adverse attention has improved. IK identifies three phases of questioning for a person returning to Istanbul airport.
14. The first is that the person will present himself to border control which is staffed by the border police. This is of course the step that all passengers face when entering a country whether or not it is their own country. The border police check the details of the person’s travel document and decide whether the person will be allowed to enter. This Appellant will not have a standard passport, but a travel document issued in the United Kingdom. He has never held a passport. It must in our judgment be likely that this will at the very least raise suspicions and that he would not be allowed to simply pass through. Indeed, this is accepted by Ms Arif in her submissions. The next phase according to IK is that he would be transferred to the airport police station for further questioning.
15. IK indicates that this further questioning is likely to take between 6 and 9 hours. In such circumstances we cannot accept Ms Arif’s submission that this questioning would be routine and simply to establish identity. The indication from IK is that it would be lengthy. There may be no ill treatment at this stage but it is likely to be a challenging interview. Dependent upon the view taken by the interviewing officers in this second phase the Appellant would be at risk of being transferred to the anti-terror police for further enquiries. IK indicates that it is at this third phase that that the prospect of material ill treatment, including torture, arises.
16. This is where we must return to the Appellant’s profile as a person returning to Türkiye after an absence of a number of years having left and indeed returned in an irregular fashion. Enquiries at the second phase are likely to reveal what the Tribunal has found to be the established facts. The Appellant is Kurdish from Gaziantep in Eastern Türkiye, his paternal uncle is a member of the Gulen movement, he was the general manager of a factory linked to the Gulen movement and his wages were paid into Asya Bank where he held an account. The sheer number of those investigated for links to Gulen (over 3 million according to a Stockholm Center for Freedom report of 27 November 2025) highlights that the authorities can consider perfectly lawful activities which they associate with the Gulen movement (such as having had an account at Asya Bank) as grounds for terrorism-related charges (see Stockholm Center for Freedom report of 15 July 2025). A person does not have to have had a high profile in the Gulen movement to be investigated. We accept Mr Collins’ submission that the translation of footnote 100 does not indicate that the State would only hold those at higher levels of the organisation criminally responsible (paragraph 8.4.1 of the CPIN),
17. There has not been past interest in the Appellant, but that is not an indication that there would be no interest now, at the point of return. We were pointed to the arbitrary way in which the Turkish authorities operate and, importantly, that the Justice Minister had announced a more determined crackdown against the Gulen movement in April 2026 (briefing note Federal Office for Migration and Refugees, Germany) and President Erdogan had vowed to continue the campaign against the movement when he spoke at a ceremony in parliament in July 2026 marking the 10th anniversary of the coup. This comes against the background of what the Human Rights Watch report on the events of 2025 described as the government consolidating its authoritarian trajectory. There must in our judgement be a real risk (and we remind ourselves that the standard is low – even a 10% chance of facing persecution may amount to a real risk – MAH (Egypt) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2023] EWCA Civ 216) that the Appellant answering the questions put to him during the potentially lengthy second phase will be moved to the third phase where he will be at real risk of material ill treatment contrary to Article 3 ECHR amounting to persecution.
18. For the reasons above we are satisfied that the accepted profile of the Appellant is reasonably likely to bring him to the adverse attention of the Turkish authorities upon return and that such adverse attention is likely to involve mistreatment amounting to persecution.
Notice of Decision
The appeal is allowed.
Judge J F W Phillips
Deputy Judge of the Upper Tribunal
26 October 2026