UI-2026-002074
- Case title:
- Appellant name:
- Status of case: Unreported
- Hearing date:
- Promulgation date:
- Publication date:
- Last updated on:
- Country:
- Judges:
The decision
IN THE UPPER TRIBUNAL
IMMIGRATION AND ASYLUM CHAMBER Case No: UI-2026-002074
First-tier Tribunal No: PA/50877/2024
THE IMMIGRATION ACTS
Decision & Reasons Issued:
On 3 November 2026
Before
UPPER TRIBUNAL JUDGE O’BRIEN
Between
MA
(ANONYMITY ORDER MADE)
Appellant
and
SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT
Respondent
Representation:
For the Appellant: Mr J Doerfel of Counsel, instructed by Buckingham Legal Services
For the Respondent: Mrs K Khan, Senior Home Office Presenting Officer
Heard at Field House on 7 August 2026
Order Regarding Anonymity
Pursuant to rule 14 of the Tribunal Procedure (Upper Tribunal) Rules 2008, the appellant is granted anonymity.
No-one shall publish or reveal any information, including the name or address of the appellant, likely to lead members of the public to identify the appellant. Failure to comply with this order could amount to a contempt of court.
DECISION AND REASONS
1. The appellant is a national of Pakistan born in June 1980. He appeals against a decision of the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) dated 11 February 2026 dismissing his appeal against the respondent’s refusal dated 27 December 2023 of his protection claim.
2. The basis of the appellant's protection claim, made on 12 February 2020, was a fear of harm from a criminal gang (although apparently related to his political activities as President of the Muslim Student Federation). However, by the time of his hearing before the FTT, the appellant sought to rely on his sur place political activities on behalf of the Pakistan Tehreek e-Insaf (PTI).
3. As recorded in the challenged decision, the respondent had accepted that the appellant was a member of the Muslim Student Federation (MSF), the student wing of the Pakistan Muslim League (Nawaz) (PML-N), but not that he was at risk as claimed. The respondent consented to the FTT dealing with the claimed sur place activities, but submitted that they were insincere and in any event would lead to no real risk on return to Pakistan.
4. I should add that they were not a ‘new matter’, having been considered in a supplementary decision dated 29 August 2025. However, given the respondent’s consent, nothing turns on the FTT’s misapprehension that they were.
5. The FTT rejected the appellant's claim to have attracted the adverse attention of a criminal gang, noting in any event the appellant's evidence that its leader appeared to have been killed, and that there was no evidence that the individual had had any reach or influence within the political system of Pakistan. The FTT found that the appellant had opportunistically abandoned his fear of the gang, in the same way that he had changed his affiliation from the PML-N to the PTI, in order to found a claim based on sur place activities [33].
6. The appellant's application for permission to appeal was granted by the FTT on limited grounds; however, permission was granted on all remaining grounds by Upper Tribunal Judge Sheridan in a decision dated 15 May 2026. His grounds of appeal are in short are as follows. The FTT impermissibly required corroboration of events in Pakistan, and applied too high a standard of proof to the case. The FTT's categorization of the appellant as a low level activist was impermissible on the evidence. The FTT failed properly to engage with the country expert evidence. The FTT's Article 8 assessment was inadequate, in particular regarding the affects of the appellant's mental health issues. The FTT failed to undertake a Holistic assessment of risk.
7. In her rule 24 response, the respondent mistakenly considered permission to appeal to have been refused on grounds 1 and 4. As noted above, permission to appeal on those grounds was granted on renewal to the Upper Tribunal. The respondent argued that it had been open to the FTT to find that the appellant was a low level activist. In particular, the appellant had failed to establish that his family had received any adverse attention, as would otherwise have been expected in accordance with the background evidence. The country expert’s opinion had been predicated on the assumption that the appellant had been telling the truth. The expert had not suggested that the appellant would be at risk if his activities were insincere.
8. The representatives each supplemented their respective party’s pleadings with oral submissions. Whilst I refer below only to such matters as necessary to understand my reasons, I took the pleadings, submissions and material to which they referred into account in the their entirety.
Ground 1
9. In support of his assertion that the Pakistan army was aware of his sur place activities, and that he was consequentially at risk, the appellant relied on ‘stills’ from a CCTV recording, said to have been taken by a security camera at his parents' house and showing a raid on that house. In respect of that evidence, the appellant said the following in a witness statement dated 7 February 2025 (names anonymised to prevent jigsaw identification):
‘7. On 04 November 2024, the Pakistani Army raided my family home due to my political activities in the UK. They took my father, [X], and brother, [Y], away to the police station, Thana Race Course. The Pakistani army told my father and brother to convey a message to me. They told them to tell me to cease my activities in the UK and further demanded that I make a video declaration confirming that I no longer have any ties with PTI or Imran Khan. They threatened that if I did not do this, there will be serious consequences for me and my family in Pakistan. My brother and father both told the Army that they have cut ties with me for so many years and have no contact with me. They threatened that next time they would do worse to him and my whole family. They even threatened to make compromising videos of my family members and leaking the videos online. They have done this to the family members of other PTI workers in order to threaten and silence them. They also said that they would not hesitate to implicate my father and brother in false criminal cases. My father was released after a few hours, but they kept my brother detained for 24 hours during which time he was mistreated and abused. He was slapped repeatedly and beaten with a stick. Both my father and brother explained to them that they had cut ties with me and had not had any contact with me for years.
8. However, after this incident, my father called me to inform me what had happened. He was very upset and shaken up. He was very angry with me because they had to go through this ordeal because of me. It was very upsetting for me to know that they were treated this way. I requested my father to send me any evidence of the Army coming to our family home, and he sent me the CCTV footage of the Army entering our front gate and damaging the CCTV camera. I have adduced a link to the CCTV footage of my family home being raided by the Pakistani Army on 04 November 2024 when my brother and father were taken in a document labelled as “Asylum - You Tube - Video Link - Raid at Family home of [MA] in Pakistan on 04 November 2024” in the supplementary bundle. I have also submitted a screenshot of the WhatsApp message I received from my father on 06 November 2024 labelled as “Asylum - WhatsApp Message – [X] to [MA] - dated 06 November 2024” and evidence that this number is registered in my father’s name and CNIC number in a document labelled as “Asylum - Sim Ownership – [X] (Father of [MA] - dated 06 November 2024).” This information is accessible online on the Sim Ownership website: https://simownership.com/result/.’
10. The FTT dealt with the stills at [36] thus:
‘The Appellant has not provided any evidence that his father and brother have been arrested after a raid by the military upon his family home as a result, he asserts, of his sur place activities in the UK. There are only two stills of what may well be military or police outside a residence or building at night, which could be anywhere in Pakistan, and concerning anybody in Pakistan, and this cannot possibly establish hostile interest in the Appellant.’
11. In fairness to the FTT, the bundle page containing the stills did not give the YouTube hyperlink to the full video (although it can easily be found by following the hyperlinks given in the bundle for other YouTube videos produced by the appellant). However, the FTT did accept nevertheless that the stills showed what ‘may well be’ (suggesting acceptance of a real possibility) military or police personnel.
12. The real issue is the FTT’s clear failure to consider evidence provided by the appellant to establish the location and time of the video from which the stills were taken. That evidence comprised evidence of the video being sent by WhatsApp on 6 November 2024, two days after the claimed raid, evidence of the telephone number with which that WhatsApp account was connected, and evidence of the name and address of the individual to whom the associated SIM was registered. No consideration is given to that evidence or to the appellant’s evidence that the name and address are those of his father. In short, I am satisfied either that relevant evidence has been overlooked, inadequate reasons have been given for why that evidence is unpersuasive or a standard higher than real risk has been applied to the appellant’s claim to be of adverse attention to the Pakistani authorities.
13. In any event, the parties appear to agree that the background evidence suggests that PTI leaders have been targeted by the authorities (see in particular the FTT’s summary of the applicable CPIN at [9]). Indeed, the respondent in her rule 24 response argues at paragraph 9 that the fact that nothing had happened to the appellant’s family supports the FTT’s conclusion that he is a low level supporter. Given the extent of the appellant’s evidenced activity in the United Kingdom, and the evidence provided to support his claim that his family had been targeted, I agree that the FTT’s apparent need for further evidence of that matter crossed the line into requiring further corroborative evidence without consideration of what more might reasonably be available and so fell into legal error (see MAH (Egypt) v SSHD [2023] EWCA Civ 216 at [86]).
Ground 2
14. The FTT’s erroneous approach to the claimed raid infects its finding on the level of the appellant’s involvement with the PTI sufficiently to render it unsafe. However, its approach to the remaining evidence similarly leaves much to be desired,
15. In her response dated 29 August 2025 to the appellant’s further submissions dated 17 July 2023, and accompanying evidence, the respondent accepted that he had engaged in the sur place political activity he had described for the PTI. That activity included his being the Secretary General for the East of England unit of PTI UK, and attending a number of events posted online. The submissions, response and supporting evidence were all before the FtT. The latter included the appellant addressing a large crowd protesting the Pakistani regime’s treatment of Imran Khan (former Prime Minister and leader of the PTI), and many interviews to camera (albeit that the breadth of the broadcast audience in each case was unclear).
16. The FTT appears to reject that as evidence of the appellant’s claim to be a high-level activist on the basis that the activities ‘involved many hundreds, if not thousands of other PTI supporters in the UK’. That, respectfully, both misses the point and inadequately explains the FTT’s conclusion.
Remaining Grounds
17. It is unnecessary in the circumstances to deal with ground 3, the challenge to the FTT’s consideration of the country expert.
18. Similarly, the defects in the FTT’s approach to the appellant’s protection claim infected its assessment under Article 8 ECHR, which cannot therefore stand.
Preservation of Findings
19. I have considered whether it would be possible to preserve any of the FTT’s findings of fact, but am unpersuaded that even the FTT’s approach to the appellant’s medical situation is safe. At [50], the FTT finds in terms that the appellant has involved himself in activities which ‘would not be possible for someone suffering from dysfunctional mental health issues even if on antidepressants in my view’, without engaging with the medical expert’s opinion that the appellant was not exaggerating or feigning his mental health difficulties.
Disposal
20. I have considered whether it would be appropriate to retain the matter for remaking in the Upper Tribunal. However, given the extent of the fact-finding necessary and the errors I have identified above in the FTT’s approach, I consider it necessary to remit the appeal for a de novo hearing.
Notice of Decision
1. The decision of the First-tier Tribunal involved the making of an error on a point of law and is set aside.
2. The appeal is remitted to the First-tier Tribunal to be heard afresh by another judge with no findings preserved.
Sean O’Brien
Judge of the Upper Tribunal
Immigration and Asylum Chamber
23 October 2026