The decision



IN THE UPPER TRIBUNAL
IMMIGRATION AND ASYLUM CHAMBER Case No: UI-2026-002465
First-tier Tribunal No: PA/68251/2023
LP/07487/2024

THE IMMIGRATION ACTS

Decision & Reasons Issued:

On 3rd of November 2026

Before

DEPUTY UPPER TRIBUNAL JUDGE WILDING

Between

HAM
(ANONYMITY ORDER MADE)
Appellant
and

SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE
HOME DEPARTMENT
Respondent

Representation:
For the Appellant: Mr M Banks, Counsel, instructed by
For the Respondent: Ms A Ahmed, Senior Presenting Officer

Heard at Field House on 13 August 2026

Order Regarding Anonymity

Pursuant to rule 14 of the Tribunal Procedure (Upper Tribunal) Rules 2008, the Appellant is granted anonymity. The First-ter Tribunal had made an anonymity order and I consider it appropriate in the circumstances for it to continue balancing the Appellant’s private life rights against the open justice principle.

No-one shall publish or reveal any information, including the name or address of the appellant, likely to lead members of the public to identify the appellant. Failure to comply with this order could amount to a contempt of court.


DECISION AND REASONS
1. The Appellant [‘A’] bring this appeal against the decision of First-tier Tribunal Judge Davison, who in an decision dated 11 February 2026 dismissed A’s appeal against the decision of the Respondent [‘R’] refusing him international protection. Permission to Appeal was granted by First-tier Tribunal Judge Hollings-Tenant on 14 May 2026.

Background
2. A claims to be a citizen of Iran. He is ethnically Kurdish, and is 26 years old. He applied for asylum on 18 October 2021, this was refused by R on 7 November 2023. The central reasons being:
a. R did not accept he was Iranian.
b. R also did not accept that A had given a credible narrative as to the circumstances in which he left Iran, albeit R did accept that A was a “Kolbar”.
c. R did not accept either that A’s sur place activities would raise his risk on return.
3. The Judge’s decision found as follows:
18. Whilst I acknowledge that smugglers may live and work and on sides of the border, and the questions at interview about where the appellant lived were problematic as noted in the refusal, to the lower standard applicable, bearing in mind the above country information I find that the appellant is an Iranian national as claimed.

19. However, I do not accept that he has told a credible claim, even bearing in mind his illiteracy and age. There are variations in the accounts told which I find go to the core of the appeal. It is acknowledged within the appellant’s own evidence that there are variations. In the (SuppB 4) is an unsigned witness statement from an “Instructed Caseworker” which refers to a statement made by a previous caseworker which included corrections to the screening interview. It is submitted that this statement was never read to the appellant but utilised by the caseworker to complete the “ACQ” and this has led to discrepancies. It does not offer an explanation as to why the witness statement utilised to complete the ACQ was incorrect. It appears to have been collated by a previous caseworker to correct the screening interview. This would suggest that instructions were taken from the appellant regarding the content of his screening interview and he gave corrections. There should therefore be no reason why this statement when utilised to complete and ACQ would be incorrect.

20. In his oral evidence the appellant recounted his claim of being asked to collect a bag by his childhood friend Milad. He stated he had smuggled bags for Milad ‘more than once’. When asked for clarity on how many times he had done this he stated ‘3 or 4’. He stated the first time he had done this was in the beginning of 2019 and the last time was at the end of 2019. It was on the third occasion that he had collected a bag for Milad that he found out the contents. In his interview (SB 624) he refers to collecting bags on two occasions, this is confirmed at (SB 627 question 64). The implication from the questioning at (SB 24, questions 49 and 50) is that the appellant either knew on both occasions that he carried the bags that they contained leaflets against the Iranian regime or he only became aware on the second trip. His oral evidence at the hearing was that the appellant had collected bags on two occasions without knowing their content. It was only on the third occasion that the appellant demanded that he be informed what was in the bags.

21. Even allowing for his lack of literacy I would expect the evidence of the appellant on this core part of his claim to be consistent. Whether he has carried bags on two, three or four occasions and whether it was on the first, second or third occasion that he discovered their content I would expect to be consistent. 22. Further, in his interview (SB 627 question 67 and 68) the appellant states that his friend was a KDPI supporter but that he was not, he was ‘involved’. At the hearing the appellant confirmed this evidence. He stated he was not a supporter he did not “try that”, he did not “want to spend time to do so.” I find that the appellant had no political affiliations in Iran. I find he had no interest in politics. The appellant claims to have come from a very small village of approximately 15 or 16 houses very close to the border. He stated his father worked as a Kolbar. I find that he has followed into his father’s profession. Due to the inconsistency in the core of his claim I do not accept he has come to the adverse attention of the authorities in Iran.

23. I find the appellant came to the United Kingdom to claim asylum as an economic migrant. Despite being illiterate he engaged in political activity almost immediately. He has attended 18 – 20 demonstrations and obtained over 5000 friends on Facebook. He accepted in evidence that he doesn’t know any of these individuals and has never met them. He stated me like-minded people at the demonstrations. His Facebook account was opened almost immediately upon his arrival in the United Kingdom.

24. For the reasons given above I find that the appellant was not politically active or aware when he was in Iran. I find that those he came into contact with shortly after his arrival have assisted him in setting up a Facebook profile where he has replicated a great number of posts and attended demonstrations. Due to his lack of literacy he has no doubt received assistance in doing so. He confirmed that the hearing that he had never met any of his 5000 Facebook friends.

25. I therefore find that the appellant has created this profile and attended the demonstrations as a purely cynical ploy in attempt to secure status in the United Kingdom. I do not accept he holds any genuine political beliefs. The issue is whether these cynical actions have nevertheless placed him at risk upon return.
4. The Judge then set out extensive reference to OM v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2025] EWCA Civ 1585, before then finding:
27. Having considered this guidance and analysis and noting the similarity of fact I find that, despite the Iranian authorities “hair trigger” approach the appellant on the individual facts of this appeal would not face a well-founded fear of persecution upon return. There is no claim that his Facebook account has been monitored. There is no evidence that it has been closed down or in any way flagged. I have not found the appellant to be a genuine political activist. I find there would be no reason for him not to delete his account. The account has, in my finding, been set up solely to facilitate an asylum claim rather than as an expression of genuine political dissent / activism. At the pinch points of application for a travel document or at return as a Kurd the appellant may well be questioned. Unless he volunteered that he had disingenuously attended demonstrations and created a Facebook account there would be no reason for the authorities in Iran to be interested in him. As found above:

‘the determinative question would be what he would or could reasonably be expected to say when questioned by Iranian authorities. The Upper Tribunal concluded that S would not be expected to volunteer information about his activities which were not an expression of any genuinely held beliefs, and which had been contrived solely to enhance a false claim for asylum and to deceive the UK authorities.’

28. For the same reasons I find the appellant would not be expected to volunteer this information as they are not expression of genuinely held beliefs.

29. For the above reasons I find there is no asylum claim, no Article 3 claim and no Humanitarian Protection claim that can succeed.

30. No other grounds were advanced. For completeness I find, for the reasons given above, there are no very significant obstacles to the appellant’s possible return to Iran. He is familiar with the culture and language. He has contacts in the country. He is now 25 years of age and in good health. The factors in 117B weigh in favour of the removal of the appellant. There is a public interest in having a fair and effective system of immigration control. I find the appellant came to the United Kingdom for economic betterment and has fabricated and employed tactics to try and evidence a well-founded fear. For the reasons given above I
find no such fear exists.
5. The Judge dismissed the appeal.
6. A appealed on three grounds:
a. The Judge failed to take a material consideration into account and/or made a material mistake of fact.
b. The Judge misapplied the HJ (Iran) and RT (Zimbabwe) principles and/or took irrelevant matters into account and/or made a finding of fact which was unsupported by evidence.
c. The Judge misapplied OM when considering the question of sur place activities.
7. Permission to appeal was granted by the FTT on 14 May 2025 on all three grounds:
2. Ground [1] asserts that the Judge erred by failing to consider the Appellant’s explanation, given in oral evidence, for inconsistencies arising from an asylum questionnaire (ACQ). There is some merit in this contention. The Judge refers to an application by the Appellant’s legal representative to ask questions in evidence in chief as to credibility issues not addressed in the witness statement (see paragraphs [2] and [11]) but arguably fails to consider the explanation given for discrepancies arising from the ACQ.

3. Ground [2] argues that the Judge erred by focusing on whether or not the Appellant supports a particular party when assessing political beliefs and misapplied principles set out HJ (Iran) and RT (Zimbabwe). The Judge does not explicitly refer to those authorities and whilst they were entitled to find the Appellant had no political affiliations or interest in politics whilst in Iran, it is arguable there is a lack of adequate reasoning as to his political beliefs as a Kurd who claims to oppose the regime.

4. Ground [3] argues the Judge erred in finding OM v SSHD [2025] EWCA Civ 1585 shared similar facts. It is pointed out it was not in dispute that the Appellant’s Facebook profile and a significant number of posts are publicly available. It seems to me this issue is inextricably linked with the issue of political beliefs raised in ground [2] and goes to the question of risk on return.

5. As such, I consider the grounds have identified at least arguable material errors of law. Permission to appeal is granted on all three grounds advanced.

The hearing
8. At the hearing I heard submissions from both representatives. Mr Banks submitted that the Judge failed to give reasons for rejecting the explanation provided by A to the Asylum Questionnaire [‘ACQ’], had the Judge have given reasons then A would understand why his evidence was rejected, but he did not and A does not know why his evidence on this was rejected.
9. Ground two and three can be taken together. The Judge inadvertently confuses interest in a political party with an interest in politics. The Judge finds A has no interest in the KDPI which is consistent with A’s evidence, however the Judge makes no findings on A’s political beliefs in relation to the oppression of Kurdish people.
10. Ground three, the Judge finds that A’s case is on all fours with that in OM. However the facts are very different. In the instant case A has 5000 Facebook friends and connections, the FTT had all 913 pages of downloaded Facebook content, and yet makes no findings on it. The Judge has relied exclusively on the analysis in OM without undertaking a separate assessment as to whether any of the risk to A from the factors in the relevant country guidance would be encountered on arrival in Iran.
11. Ms Ahmed, on behalf of R, submitted there was no error of law. In relation to Ground One the Judge did consider the evidence as outlined at §2 of his decision. The Judge at §19 she said considers the explanation. In any event any error on Ground One was not material given the findings from §20.
12. Ground two and three, A has failed to show an error in the findings. The grounds amount to little more than a disagreement, and the Judge followed the guidance he was suppose to. Taken as whole R submitted that the Judge had made the relevant findings as required.

Decision and reasons
13. I am grateful to both representatives for their submissions, I mean no disrespect to either by not setting them out in detail. I am sorry that it has taken longer than anticipated for this decision to be finalised, I was clear in my mind what my decision was going to be on the day of the hearing. I have reminded myself of my record of proceedings, along with the documentary evidence filed.
14. I do consider that the Judge erred as advanced. I consider both substantive complaints to be made out.
15. In relation to Ground One I agree with Mr Banks that the Judge failed to explain why he rejected A’s explanation in his oral evidence on the ACQ issue. As the grounds identify, that explanation included:
a. The answers taken by the caseworker from him were on a WhatsApp call
b. That the interpretation were not good
c. That the questions were not clear to him
16. As Mr Banks candidly accepted, the Judge did not have to accept that evidence, but he has to give reasons if he rejects it. The Judge appears to have not taken it into account when he finds the A’s evidence on a central point is not accepted. I consider this ground to be made out.
17. Similarly I find the other Grounds are made out. The Judge fails in my judgment to properly considered whether A has political opinions which would put him at risk, the rejection of this by reference to A never being a supporter of the KDPI in my judgment misses the point of A’s case. He is politically engaged, just not a supporter of a particular party. This failure in my judgment has impacted the Judge’s assessment of the claim as a whole, and in particular has infected the sur place claim.
18. Furthermore, the Judge has failed to adequately explain why the instant case is on all fours with OM. I agree with Mr Banks that on the face of the evidence before him, the case was in fact not at all similar to that in OM. A has provided his full Facebook profile, his clear evidence is that it is a public account, and that he is politically engaged. The facts of OM were:
“…Judge Power said that she was not satisfied that the appellant was active on social media. The evidence consisted of screenshots of posts, the last of which was dated November 2023. There was no evidence that the posts had remained public beyond the taking of the screenshots and nothing to confirm the appellant’s Facebook account remained publicly available.”
19. On the face of things A’s case is not at all the same as in OM, certainly not until some sound findings of fact have been made. In my judgment the Judge’s reasoning therefore is inadequate.
20. His decision is set aside such that it cannot stand. I consider that the matter cannot sensibly be determined in the Upper Tribunal without substantial evidence to be heard. I consider that the only appropriate forum for this appeal is for it to be remitted to the FTT to be reheard.
21. I have paused as to whether the finding of A’s nationality should be retained or that it is infected by the Judge’s overall approach. I consider that §18 is limited by way of reasoning, I acknowledge that there has been no cross appeal by R on this. I consider that in relation to the finding of A’s nationality that on balance the finding should be retained. The Judge, just about, gives enough reasons for why he finds A is Iranian. It may well be, had it have been challenged that it would not have stood up to scrutiny, however absent hearing any argument on the point I do not consider it so clearly unreasoned that I should find that the finding is set aside. That said there would be nothing preventing R from raising the issue again should further evidence come to light that undermines the Judge’s finding.

Notice of Decision
The First-tier Tribunal Judge materially erred in law.
The decision of the FTT is set aside and the appeal is remitted to the FTT with no findings preserved other than the finding at §17-18 that the Appellant is an Iranian national.


Judge T.S. Wilding

Deputy Judge of the Upper Tribunal
Immigration and Asylum Chamber


Date: 29th October 2026