The decision



IN THE UPPER TRIBUNAL
IMMIGRATION AND ASYLUM CHAMBER Case No: UI-2026-003451 / UI-2026-003452
/ UI-2026-003453
First-tier Tribunal No: EU/52429/2024
/ EU/52430/2024 / EU/52431/2024

THE IMMIGRATION ACTS

Decision & Reasons Issued:

4th November 2026

Before

UPPER TRIBUNAL JUDGE LOUGHRAN

Between

FAUZIA SENA TUTUWAA
JOSEPH KEYI AGYEI
WILLIAM OPPONG-TWUMASI
(NO ANONYMITY ORDER MADE)
Appellant
and

THE SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT
Respondent

Representation:
For the Appellant: Mr A Jafar, Counsel instructed by Gordon and Thompson Solicitors
For the Respondent: Ms A Ahmed, Senior Home Office Presenting Officer

Heard at Field House on 14 October 2026


DECISION AND REASONS
INTRODUCTION
1. The Appellants appeal with the permission of the First-tier Tribunal against the decision of the First-tier Tribunal dismissing the Appellants’ appeals against the Respondent’s decisions refusing their applications to join a family member under the European Union Settlement Scheme (“EUSS”).
2. The Appellants claim that they are the adult children of Isaac Kajeau (“the Sponsor”), who is a citizen of the Netherlands living in the United Kingdom.
Background
3. In their applications the Appellants provided the following evidence of their identity and relationship with the Sponsor.
a. Handwritten birth certificates which, in his witness statement, the Sponsor claims are issued to every Ghanaian child born at a health facility in Ghana.
b. Biometric birth certificates.
c. Documents signed by a Senior Legal Officer attesting that the stamp, signature and seal on the birth certificate is that of a notary.
d. Documents from the Births and Deaths Registry verifying the birth certificates and stating that they had been “officially processed and entered in the register of Berekum in the Brong Ahafo Region”.
e. A document from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Regional Integration confirming that the signature of the notary on the birth certificates is that of a true and certified Senior Legal Officer.
f. DNA results in respect of each of the Appellants stating that the probability of paternity for all of them was over 99%, and passports.
4. In decisions dated 13 March 2024, the Respondent refused the Appellants’ applications. The Respondent stated that the Department had sought verification of the birth certificates issued by the Ghanaian authorities, who had confirmed to them that the birth certificates were not genuine.
5. The Respondent noted that the details were reported in a Document Verification Report (“DVR 1”) and the Respondent concluded that she was satisfied that the Appellants had provided false or misleading information submitted to a person to obtain a document used in support of an application.
6. DVR 1 is dated 26 February 2024. It states that the Appellants’ birth certificates had been found to be false. It records contact with a named Senior Assistant Registrar and that “the contact has completed internal checks and has responded through official means that the document has been assessed as fraudulent”.
The Appeal to the First-tier Tribunal
7. The Appellants lodged appeals against the Respondent’s refusal of their human rights claims.
8. In addition to the evidence they submitted with their applications the Appellants relied on evidence from a Justice of the Supreme Court of Judicature, High Court Land Division, Accra, dated 2 July 2024. His evidence included the following:
a. There is no centralised office in Ghana where all births and deaths are registered.
b. Handwritten birth certificates are issued at local offices and are valid for 12 months.
c. The process of digitalisation of the database of the Births and Deaths Registry only commenced approximately two years ago, so in around 2022.
d. The best source for reliable information about the birth of a Ghanaian is their Municipal District Assembly and a search from a different Municipal District Assembly would return a result of “not traced”.
e. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Ghana verifies all birth certificates from the different Municipal District Assemblies where they had been issued before issuing passports for an individual. Having reviewed the birth certificates, he considered them to be genuine and stated that if they had not been, the individuals would not have been issued with passports.
f. The individual named in the DVR as a contact is not in the correct department where the verification of birth certificates ought to have been undertaken.
g. Verification ought to have been sought from the local office for each of the Appellants’ births as registration is not centralised.
9. In addition, the Appellants relied on further documents dated 30 July 2024 from a Registrar of Births and Deaths at the Births and Deaths Registry. Those letters stated in respect of each of the Appellants: “We acknowledge receipt of your refusal letter”, and gave the reference number, stating, “We wish to inform you that the birth certificate with entry number”, and gave the entry numbers of each birth certificate, “presented by the Appellants, is genuine and authentic”. The letter in respect of Fauzia Sena Tutuwaa states that the birth certificate was registered at Berekum in the Berekum Municipal Assembly on 3 July 2003. The letter in respect of Joseph Keyi Agyei states that the birth certificate was registered in Berekum in the Berekum Municipal Assembly on 6 November 2003. Finally, in respect of William Oppong-Twumasi, it states that the birth certificate was registered at Adum in the Kumasi Metropolitan Assembly on 11 October 2004.
10. The Appellants also provided certified copies of their birth certificates.
The Respondent’s Review
11. The Respondent reconsidered the case and provided a review dated 13 September 2024. The Respondent relied on a further DVR (‘DVR2’) in support of her case. DVR2 stated the following:
“As a guide to the verification process undertaken by UKVI Accra, an electronic copy of the attached document is printed and physically taken to the Medina branch of the Births and Deaths Registry (BDR) by an Entry Clearance Assistant within the United Kingdom Visas and Immigration (UKVI) team based in the British High Commission in Accra. The official at the BDR checks the document against the central registration of birth to verify there is a trace of the record existing on the central register. Where there is no record in the central register and where a birth has been registered in the regional office outside Accra, the regional office in question will be contacted by the local BDR officials to verify the record against their own registers and return their findings to the Medina branch for when UKVI next attends their office. A copy of the attached birth certificate was resent to the Medina branch of the Births and Deaths Registry for verification during the period of September 2025. On 5 September 2025 we received from the officials at the Births and Deaths Registry confirmation that there is no trace of this birth having been recorded.”
[…]
"The result of the BDR was that there was no trace of this birth having been registered as per the details contained in the certificate and it is therefore considered to be non-genuine."
12. An email exchange is included in DVR 2. The parties agreed in court that the email exchange states the following:
“Dear Maxwell,
I hope you are well. The attached cases were shared with the BDR and they were returned as not traced. However, the applicants have now provided letters claiming the BCs are genuine. They have also provided new copies of the BCs with genuine stamps on them. We would be grateful if the attached please could be verified soon. Also, we would appreciate if they could be verified as they are urgent.”

“Hi, the letters attached are not from our department.”
13. There is a further line of writing that the parties agreed is not legible.
The decision of the First-tier Tribunal
14. The Appellants’ appeals came before the Judge on 6 March 2026. The Sponsor gave oral evidence. The First-tier Tribunal dismissed the appeals in a decision dated 8 March 2026.
15. The First-tier Tribunal considered the dispute over the birth certificates and came to the following conclusions:
“It appears from the efforts made by the Respondent that the appropriate inquiries of the local registry office were made as part of the document verification process. The report sets out very clearly that the inquiries are made of local registry office where no trace of a birth certificate is found centrally. Whether the terminology used about a birth certificate that cannot be traced is ‘false’ or ‘fraudulent’ or ‘non-genuine’, the conclusion remains that the Appellant has not provided birth certificates which are verified through the Respondent’s searches.
The Respondent has shown that inquiries were made of local registry office and no records were found with details corresponding to the birth certificates provided by the Appellant. As a result of this I do not accept the Appellants’ argument that I can ignore the birth certificate and take both the passports and the DNA results at face value and accept the claimed relationship to the Sponsor.
The birth certificates are the underlying documents for both the passports and thereafter the DNA identification process. Therefore, a question mark over the validity of the birth certificates casts a doubt on all the identity documents that flow from those certificates.
Despite submissions from the Appellants that I should ignore this, I do not find it is open to me or indeed reasonable for me to take the results of the DNA process and the issuing of passports on trust.
I do not find therefore that the Appellants have established on the balance of probabilities that they are related to the Sponsor as they have claimed. Therefore, they do not meet the requirements of the EUSS.”
The Appeal to the Upper Tribunal
16. The Appellants appealed to the Upper Tribunal relying on four grounds:
Ground 1: the First-tier Tribunal failed to adequately engage with the evidence and gave a disproportionate amount of weight to the DVR.

Ground 2: the First-tier Tribunal failed to consider that the Secretary of State had the burden of proof in respect of whether the birth certificates were false.

Ground 3: the First-tier Tribunal failed to have regard to the evidence that the Appellants could not have got passports without birth certificates.

Ground 4: the First-tier Tribunal erred in dismissing the DNA evidence.
17. In a decision dated 29 June 2026, permission to appeal was granted by the First-tier Tribunal stating:
Grounds [1] and [2] assert the Judge erred by failing to give adequate weight to relevant expert evidence, affording disproportionate weight to a document verification report and failing to apply the correct burden of proof. There is some merit in these assertions for the reason advanced. The Respondent argued the birth certificates adduced were false and, as such, bore the burden of proof in respect of that allegation. The Judge does not self-direct nor refer to relevant authorities on this issue and instead notes the burden of proof is on the Appellants (at paragraph [5]).

Grounds [3] to [5] argue the Judge erred in failing to make findings on material evidence, dismissing DNA evidence on an illogical basis and failing to consider evidence in the round. There is some merit in these contentions. It seems to me that the Judge relies upon findings regarding the birth certificates to essentially disregard other relevant documentary evidence without considering such evidence in the round (at paragraph [12]). It is unclear whether the Judge had regard to expert evidence on the issuing of passports or properly considered the weight to be placed on DNA evidence with reference to the process by which it was obtained or whether the report was from an accredited laboratory.
18. The Respondent provided three responses under rule 24 of the Tribunal Procedure (Upper Tribunal) Rules 2008 (rule 24 response). Two are dated 16 July and one is dated 17 July. The rule 24 response dated 17 July conceded the appeal. In correspondence prior to the hearing, the Respondent confirmed that she opposed the appeal and did not rely on the rule 24 response dated 17 July. Ms Ahmed confirmed this at the hearing and that she relied on the two rule 24 responses dated 16 July 2026.
19. At the hearing before me I heard submissions from Mr Jafar on behalf of the Appellants and Ms Ahmed on behalf of the Respondent. At the end of the hearing I indicated that I was satisfied that the Judge had made a material error of law and that my decision would follow in writing.
Discussion.
20. I can address the Appellants’ grounds together.
21. In Tanveer Ahmed v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2002] UKIAT 00439, the IAT explained that the burden would fall on the Home Office to prove that a document was a forgery only where the document was apparently reliable. It considered that it would usually be necessary for the Home Office to contend that a document was forged in order to dispute its reliability. The Tribunal summarised the principles set out in the decision at [38]:
1. In asylum and human rights cases it is for an individual claimant to show that a document on which he seeks to rely can be relied on.

2. The decision maker should consider whether a document is one on which reliance should properly be placed after looking at all the evidence in the round.

3. Only very rarely will there be the need to make an allegation of forgery, or evidence strong enough to support it. The allegation should not be made without such evidence. Failure to establish the allegation on the balance of probabilities to the higher civil standard does not show that a document is reliable. The decision maker still needs to apply principles 1 and 2.
22. The Upper Tribunal addressed Tanveer Ahmed in the recent case of Hoxha and others (Tanveer Ahmed - fraudulent applications - procedure) [2026] UKUT 00378. The Upper Tribunal reaffirmed what was said in Tanveer Ahmed and in addition added that the overarching question for the Judge will be whether the document in question can be regarded as reliable looking at all the evidence in the round.
Approach to the Evidence
23. The Sponsor provided a witness statement and oral evidence. It is the Sponsor’s evidence that the Appellants are his children. He also states that all the Appellants were issued with handwritten birth certificates and that they were issued to every Ghanaian child born at a health facility in Ghana. He records that the Appellants’ birth certificates have been verified by the Births and Deaths Registry and the Foreign Affairs Ministry and that subsequently, after it had been found that their birth certificates were not genuine, they returned to seek clarification and that the Births and Deaths Registry issued a verification letter to them. The Sponsor also states that he has sent money regularly for his children’s day-to-day expenditure. He talks to them almost daily and that he visits them in Ghana on family events and holidays.
24. The Sponsor’s evidence is not referred to in the First-tier Tribunal decision. There is no finding as to whether the Sponsor’s evidence that the Appellants are his children was accepted or rejected.
25. The First-tier Tribunal records that the DVR ‘sets out very clearly that inquiries are made of local registry offices where no trace of a birth certificate is found centrally’. However, having reviewed the DVRs there is no reference to those inquiries having been made in the Appellants’ case. The First-tier Tribunal did not give adequate reasons why they were satisfied that in this particular case inquiries had been made of the local registry offices.
26. The Appellants sought to rely on various documents verifying, certifying and supporting their birth certificates from a Senior Legal Officer, from the Births and Deaths Registry and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. They subsequently returned to the Births and Deaths Registry and received additional verification of their passports.
27. There is no reference to this evidence anywhere in the First-tier Tribunal’s decision. There is also no reference to the expert’s opinion that the Appellants would not have been able to obtain passports without birth certificates.
28. I am satisfied that all of that evidence is material to the First-tier Tribunal’s consideration and by failing to consider it the First-tier Tribunal materially erred in law.
29. The First-tier Tribunal failed to consider whether reliance should properly be placed on the birth certificates after looking at all the evidence in the round because the First-tier Tribunal excluded relevant evidence from its consideration.
The Burden of Proof
30. Ms Ahmed accepted that as the Respondent was asserting that the documents were false, the burden of proof is on the Respondent. That is not recorded anywhere in the First-tier Tribunal’s decision.
31. I note that the First-tier Tribunal is an expert Tribunal. However, I am satisfied that it is clear from the language used in the decision that the First-tier Tribunal did not approach this matter as though the Respondent had the burden of proof. For example, at [12] the First-tier Tribunal concludes that there is ‘a question mark over the validity of the birth certificates which casts doubt on all the identity documents that flow from those certificates.’
32. For the reasons, given above I am satisfied that the First-tier Tribunal materially erred in law and the decision should be set aside.
Disposal
33. Applying AEB [2022] EWCA Civ 1512 and Begum (Remaking or remittal) Bangladesh [2023] UKUT 00046 (IAC), I have considered whether to retain the matter for remaking in the Upper Tribunal in line with the general principles set out in paragraph 7 of the Senior President’s Practice Statements.
34. As I outlined above, I indicated to the parties at the hearing that I was satisfied that the First-tier had made material errors of law. Mr Jafar submitted that the matter should be remitted to the First-tier Tribunal. Ms Ahmed stated that the Secretary of State was neutral.
35. I am satisfied that in the circumstances where the Judge failed to have regard to relevant evidence it is appropriate to remit the matter back to the First-tier Tribunal.
Notice of Decision
1. The decision of the First-tier Tribunal involved the making of material errors of law and is set aside with no findings of fact preserved.
2. The appeal is remitted to the First-tier Tribunal to be heard afresh by a different Judge.

G. Loughran

Judge of the Upper Tribunal
Immigration and Asylum Chamber

30 October 2026