The decision



IN THE UPPER TRIBUNAL
IMMIGRATION AND ASYLUM CHAMBER Case No: UI-2026-003592
First-tier Tribunal No: PA/04800/2024
PA/65120/2024

THE IMMIGRATION ACTS

Decision & Reasons Issued:

4th November 2026

Before

UPPER TRIBUNAL JUDGE O’BRIEN

Between

AY
(ANONYMITY ORDER MADE)
Appellant
and

SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT
Respondent

Representation:
For the Appellant: In person
For the Respondent: Mr E Tyrell, Senior Home Office Presenting Officer

Heard at Field House on 9 October 2026

Order Regarding Anonymity

Pursuant to rule 14 of the Tribunal Procedure (Upper Tribunal) Rules 2008, the appellant is granted anonymity.

No-one shall publish or reveal any information, including the name or address of the appellant, likely to lead members of the public to identify the appellant. Failure to comply with this order could amount to a contempt of court.


DECISION AND REASONS

1. The appellant appeals against a decision of the First-tier Tribunal (FtT) dated 29 May 2026 dismissing his appeal against the respondent’s decision dated 10 April 2024 refusing his protection and human rights claim.

2. The appellant is a national of Nigeria born in July 2005. The basis of his claim was a fear of forcible recruitment by bandits and/or a gang called Yan Banga, and also a fear of violence from the Indigenous People of Biafra (IPOB) because of his ethnicity and IPOB’s consequential belief that he was associated with Boko Haram. The respondent accepted none of the appellant’s claim save for his identity and nationality.

3. The FtT did not find the appellant a credible witness and so accept that the appellant’s account was even reasonably likely to be true. The FtT found that the appellant would in any event have sufficiency of protection and would be able safely and reasonably to relocate internally to avoid any risk.

The Parties’ Respective Positions

4. Permission to appeal was granted on all grounds by the FtT in a decision dated 2 July 2026. The pleaded grounds can be summarised as follows.

5. The FtT gave inadequate reasons for its adverse credibility findings. The FtT failed to consider the appellant’s age and vulnerability when assessing credibility. The FtT made speculative findings. The FtT misapplied the test for internal relocation by failing to consider whether it would be reasonable for the appellant in his particular circumstances. The FtT placed unfair reliance on the appellant’s screening interview and failed to consider properly the reason for the appellant’s refusal to be substantively interviewed (the inability to source a Hausa interpreter). Whilst the application comprised 7 numbered grounds, grounds 2 and 6 overlap significantly, as do grounds 4 and 7, and it is convenient to deal with each of those pairs together.

6. The appellant appeared in person and was content for the grounds to speak for themselves. Mr Tyrell made oral submissions which in short defended the FtT’s findings as reasonably open to it, with there being no proper basis to find that the FtT had overlooked the appellant’s age and vulnerability when assessing his evidence. He further submitted that the appellant had not challenged the FtT’s finding that he would have sufficiency of protection, rendering all of the pleaded errors immaterial.

7. While I refer below only to such matters as necessary to understand my decision, I took the statements of case, oral submissions and the materials to which they refer into account in their entirety.

Consideration

Ground 1

8. The suggestion that the FtT failed to give adequate reasons for its adverse credibility findings is hopeless. Those findings are principally found between [35] and [52], some 18 substantial paragraphs containing detailed reasons for finding several matters fatally damaging to the appellant’s credibility. For instance, a significant inconsistency in the chronology is analysed over 5 paragraphs and inconsistencies in the appellant’s evidence of those he feared is analysed over a further 8 paragraphs. The reasons given by the FtT for why it found the appellant’s account incredible were more than adequate for a reasonable individual to understand that finding.

Grounds 2 and 6

9. The appellant was 20 years old at the date of the hearing. Nevertheless, the FtT recorded at [7] that he was accompanied by his ‘foster carer’, and at [57] the appellant’s claim that he had been sent away from Nigeria by his mother. Moreover, the FtT directed itself expressly at [39] to the appellant’s age at the time of the claimed material events and screening, as well as to the Joint Presidential Guidance Note on Child, Vulnerable Adult and Sensitive Appellants. It referred again to the appellant’s age on arrival at [52]. The FtT expressly records having considered the appellant’s account in light of his age and maturity. There is nothing in the FtT’s analysis which gives cause to doubt that it did in fact keep those matters in mind, as well as his only support being that of a foster carer, when assessing the appellant’s credibility.

10. On the contrary, the FtT records at[ 11] that it directed that the respondent signposted the Appellant to the questions that were being put to him and to ensure that he questions were kept short to allow him to understand what was being asked of him. There was no error in the FtT’s approach to the appellant’s vulnerabilities.

Ground 3

11. It was for the appellant to prove his claim that he was sent away from Nigeria due to a well-founded fear of persecution. The FtT found that he had not. For the reasons given above and below, that was a conclusion open to the FtT. Whilst nothing therefore turned on the FtT’s finding that he had instead been sent away by his mother for a better life (and so any such error would have been immaterial), it was nevertheless a permissible finding given the appellant’s evidence that he came from a poor region of Nigeria which did not have many employment opportunities [57].

Grounds 4 and 7

12. Given the FtT’s permissible rejection of the factual foundation of the claim, any error in its analysis of internal relocation was immaterial. As it is, the grounds fail to explain why a 20-year old Nigerian adult with no claimed significant medical difficulties would be unable reasonably to relocate to Kano or Abuja (where his principal language is spoken), even without family or other support network, let alone how his care leaver status was relevant to that assessment. No error of law is disclosed in these grounds.

Ground 5

13. The FtT expressly records that the appellant’s screening interview had been conducted in English and that he submitted there were consequential significant inaccuracies used by the respondent to undermine his credibility [32]. It also recorded that no substantive interview had been conducted because a Hausa interpreter could not be sourced [34]. Nevertheless, the appellant was assisted at the FtT hearing by a Hausa interpreter [6]. The grounds do not assert that there was any issue with interpretation at the hearing. Moreover, the FtT noted that the appellant had confirmed at the send of his screening interview that he had understood all the questions and did not with to add or change anything [33].

14. It cannot be said that the FtT failed to take into account the language in which the screening interview was conducted or the lack of substantive interview. I have already found above that the FtT had due regard to the appellant’s age. The FtT gave careful consideration to the effect of language and age when considering his answers given at screening and when assessing credibility. The approach was permissible, in particular with permissible weight attached to the screening interview, and there is no identifiable error in the subsequent analysis.

15. In conclusion, none of the grounds disclose any error of law in the FtT’s analysis or conclusions, and the appeal is dismissed.

Notice of Decision

1. The decision of the First-tier Tribunal did not involve the making of an error on a point of law and so stands undisturbed.


Sean O’Brien

Judge of the Upper Tribunal
Immigration and Asylum Chamber


29 October 2026