The decision



IN THE UPPER TRIBUNAL
IMMIGRATION AND ASYLUM CHAMBER Case No: UI-2026-004081
First-tier Tribunal No: HU/65407/2024


THE IMMIGRATION ACTS


Decision & Reasons Issued:
On 2 November 2026


Before

UPPER TRIBUNAL JUDGE KEBEDE


Between

TN
(Anonymity Order made)
Appellant
and

SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE HOME DEPARTMENT
Respondent

Representation:
For the Appellant: Mr C Timson, instructed by Deus Nexus Solicitors Ltd
For the Respondent: Dr S Ibisi, Senior Home Office Presenting Officer

Heard at Manchester Civil Justice Centre on 9 October 2026


DECISION AND REASONS

1. The appellant appeals, with permission, against the decision of the First-tier Tribunal which dismissed his appeal against the respondent’s decision to refuse his asylum and human rights claim.

2. The appellant is a national of Vietnam born on 2 April 2002. He arrived in the UK by boat on 29 April 2024 and claimed asylum on 30 April 2024. On 30 April 2024 a referral was made on the appellant’s behalf to the National Referral Mechanism (NRM) in order for the Competent Authorities to make a decision as to whether he was a victim of modern slavery. The appellant’s asylum claim was refused on 20 October 2024. He appealed against that decision..

3. The appellant claimed to be at risk from the Vietnamese authorities following his escape from a police station after being arrested at a demonstration on 13 July 2022 against the government’s decision to close the only road leading to the village. His evidence in his screening interview was that he left Vietnam by boat to China on 25 March 2024 and stayed in China for two days before being brought by agents to France and then by boat to the UK. He later claimed that the person who took him out of Vietnam had told him to say that, but he actually left Vietnam on 20 July 2022 and was taken in the container of a lorry to China where he was forced to work for a year and seven months until April 2024 when he was put on a flight to France.

4. The respondent, in refusing the appellant’s claim, accepted that he was a national of Vietnam and accepted that he was Catholic but did not accept that he had come to the adverse attention of the Vietnamese authorities due to his political activity and did not accept that he was a potential victim of exploitation. The respondent considered that the appellant’s account of his activities at the demonstration was inconsistent and that his account of how he escaped from the police station was also inconsistent. The respondent also noted that the appellant had given different accounts of when he left Vietnam and therefore did not accept his account of exploitation in China. It was not accepted that the appellant would be at risk on return to Vietnam on the basis of his religion or political activities, or that he was at risk of being re-trafficked. It was not accepted that his return to Vietnam would breach his human rights.

5. The appellant’s appeal against that decision was heard in the First-tier Tribunal on 16 April 2026, by which time, according to the respondent, the appellant had received a negative reasonable grounds decision from the NRM. The judge noted the appellant’s account that he had participated in a peaceful protest in his village against the local authority’s decision to sell the only road leading to the village, that the road was essential for access to markets, hospitals and religious, that the appellant witnessed his maternal grandfather being struck by an officer and intervened to protect him and as a result was arrested, beaten and forced to sign a confession under duress at the police station, that he escaped from the police station through a window and fled into hiding, that a summons was issued for him and that he fled to Hanoi and later to China where he was trafficked and forced to work in a cold storage warehouse for over a year under threats of violence. The judge noted further that the appellant claimed to have since participated in a peaceful protest outside the Vietnamese Embassy in London organised by the Brotherhood for Democracy highlighting religious persecution and human rights abuses in Vietnam and feared that his participation had been recorded, that his family continued to face harassment from both the authorities and traffickers, with the police regularly visiting their home, that other villagers who were involved in the 2022 protest had been arrested and imprisoned, and that the traffickers had threatened his parents with violence and had demanded repayment. The judge noted the appellant’s claim to have been told, when he was taken from France to the UK, to memorise a false account to give to the authorities if he was encountered in the UK and that he should say that he travelled from China to France in the back of a container and not to disclose that he had used a passport to travel.

6. The judge accepted, from the background country evidence, that there was a protest in the appellant’s village which resulted in substantial police presence and some arrests. However she considered that the appellant had given an inconsistent account of his actions at the demonstration and whether he was participating in the demonstration or rushed in when he arrived and saw his grandfather being beaten. The judge considered that that inconsistency cast doubt on the credibility of the appellant’s account, as did his inconsistent account of how he escaped from the police station. The judge noted that the appellant had given a different account of when he let Vietnam, claiming in his screening interview that he left on 25 March 2024 and was forced to work for seven days in China, whereas at his asylum interview and at the hearing he was claiming to have left Vietnam in July 2022 and to have spent a year and seven months being forced to work in China. The noted that the appellant also claimed in his screening interview to have been fingerprinted and obtained his ID card in Vietnam on October 2022 whereas at the hearing he said that that was incorrect as it was October 2021. The judge did not accept the appellant’s explanation for the discrepancies and considered that they cast further doubt on the credibility of his claim. The judge referred to the documentary evidence relied upon by the appellant which he claimed to have received from his mother, consisting of a letter from his mother telling him that the authorities were searching for him, a copy of a summons dated 19 July 2022, and a letter from Thanh Tan Parish signed by Father NDT dated 5th October 2024 confirming that he had participated in the protest on 13 July 2022 and had been arrested, beaten and fled, and was thereafter being investigated and threatened by the police. The judge had doubts as to the validity of the documents and she rejected the appellant’s account of his arrest, detention and ill-treatment by the police. She considered it more likely that the appellant left Vietnam in March 2024 and therefore did not accept that he was forced to work in China for a year and seven months and did not accept his account of having been trafficked. The judge accepted that the appellant attended a demonstration in the UK but did not accept that that would put him at risk on return to Vietnam. The judge accordingly dismissed the appeal on all grounds, in a decision promulgated on 22 April 2026.

7. The appellant sought permission to appeal to the Upper Tribunal against the judge’s decision on two grounds. Firstly, that the judge had irrationally found there to be inconsistencies in the appellant’s account of his participation at the demonstration and escape from the police station. Secondly, that the judge’s reasoning for rejecting the documentary evidence was contrary to the approach required by Mibanga v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2005] EWCA Civ 367 and that she had given inadequate reasons for rejecting the documents.

8. Permission was granted in the First-tier Tribunal on all grounds, although primarily on the second ground, on the basis that “it is arguable, given the potential importance of the documents provided by the appellant, that the Judge has not given clear reasons as to why he has rejected the documents and that he has assessed the documents in light of his prior assessment of the appellant’s credibility rather than in the round.”

9. The respondent provided a rule 24 response opposing the appeal.

10. The matter then came before me for a hearing.

Hearing and Submissions

11. Both parties made submissions.

12. With regard to the first ground, Mr Timson submitted that it was difficult to see how the judge found that the appellant had given contradictory accounts of his attendance at the demonstration and that a reading of his answers to the questions at his interview showed that there was nothing contradictory in his evidence. The judge had conflated two issues. As for the second ground, Mr Timson submitted that it was clear that the judge had already formed an adverse view on credibility before considering the documentary evidence. She did not say that there was anything wrong with the documents on their face but relied only on the late production of the documents. However the documents were not submitted late. The appellant could not have obtained them earlier as he was not in contact with his mother at the time of the interview. The judge’s findings were therefore not in accordance with the principles in Tanveer Ahmed [2002] IAT 00439.

13. Dr Ibisi submitted, with regard to the first ground, that the judge had made correct observations about inconsistencies in the appellant’s account, but even if she had misunderstood that part of the account that was not material as she had noted various other inconsistencies in the evidence. There was no challenge to the judge’s findings on the inconsistencies in the appellant’s evidence about his journey to the UK and when his identity card was issued. This was therefore just one piece in the greater puzzle and there were a host of other issues. The judge gave adequate reasons for her findings. She took account of the principles in Tanveer Ahmed when making her findings on the documents. The weight to be given to the documents was a matter for the judge. There was no proper explanation for the appellant not having obtained the documents earlier.

14. In response, Mr Timson submitted that it may be the case that there were other inconsistencies, but the judge had not dealt with the documents properly. She made adverse findings on the basis of inconsistencies which did not exist and then rejected the documents on the basis of those adverse credibility findings. Her reasoning was flawed. There was no proper reason given for rejecting the summons.

Analysis

15. The first ground challenges the judge’s reliance upon apparent inconsistencies in the appellant’s account and asserts that in fact there were no inconsistencies. However it seems to me that the judge was entitled to view the appellant’s initial account, at questions 25 to 28 of the interview, that he was one of the protestors at the demonstration chanting slogans, as being different from the account given later at question 33 and 37, that he rushed into a scuffle when he arrived at the demonstration and saw the police beating his grandfather. Likewise the judge was entitled to consider the appellant’s account of climbing down a drainpipe after smashing a window at the police station (question 48), to be different from his account of jumping down (question 52). Contrary to the assertion in the grounds, I do not accept that the judge conflated the appellant’s account in respect to the first matter and, in relation to the second, failed to consider that the appellant’s answers were mutually consistent. The grounds seek to offer an explanation for what the judge perceived as inconsistencies and in that respect amount simply to a post-decision attempt to clarify matters and a disagreement with her conclusions on the evidence. The judge was perfectly entitled to consider the accounts to be sufficiently different as to undermine the credibility of the appellant’s claim in that respect.

16. In any event, as Dr Ibisi submitted, the judge’s concerns in that regard had to be considered in the context of the various other credibility issues arising in the appellant’s claim, and even if there had been some misunderstanding by the judge of the appellant’s evidence on those two issues (which I do not find there to have been) there were more significant concerns which properly led her to conclude overall that the appellant had not provided a reliable and truthful account. Those other credibility issues included the significantly different accounts provided by the appellant of when he left Vietnam and how long he spent in China, and when he obtained his identity card in Vietnam, all of which went to the core of his claim to have been trafficked in China. In addition the judge observed that the appellant had made no mention of fearing traffickers at his screening interview and considered his account of the traffickers providing him with a passport and paying for his flight to France to be lacking in credibility.

17. Not only did the appellant give differing accounts in those respects, but the judge also noted the inconsistent reasons he gave for providing the different accounts, whether it was due to the traffickers telling him to lie about his journey or whether, as mentioned by the judge at [29], there had been a mistake in his screening interview. The judge’s concerns in that regard are set out at [104] to [110] and, as Dr Ibisi submitted, none of her observations and findings in that regard have been challenged in the grounds. In the light of those significant discrepancies the judge was perfectly entitled to view the apparent differences in the appellant’s account of the demonstration and his escape from the prison as being further indications of the appellant presenting an unreliable claim. The judge was accordingly entitled to make the adverse credibility findings that she did and she gave perfectly adequate reasons for making those findings. The first ground is accordingly without merit, and indeed I note that the judge granting permission was less persuaded by that ground.

18. The second ground challenges the judge’s findings on the documents relied upon by the appellant, namely a police summons, a letter from the appellant’s mother and a letter from his priest, asserting that the judge fell into the ‘Mibanga’ error of rejecting the documents after having already formed a negative view of the appellant’s credibility and that she failed to give adequate reasons for rejecting the documents. However I do not accept that the judge fell into such an error. She properly self- directed herself on the principles in Tanveer Ahmed, as is apparent at [118] and took all the evidence together in the round. She had the benefit of submissions made about the documents as recorded earlier in her decision and she gave detailed consideration to the appellant’s explanation of the circumstances under which the documents were obtained, noting at [117] the lack of explanation as to why they were not produced earlier. On the basis of her unchallenged findings the appellant had left Vietnam almost two years after the summons was said to have been issued. In all the circumstances, and given the timing of events, it was entirely open to the judge to draw the adverse conclusions that she did with regard to the late production of the documents, and, taken together with the inconsistencies in the appellant’s account of the events to which the documents related, to have doubts about their reliability as a result.

19. For all these reasons I do not find the grounds to be made out. The judge undertook a full and careful assessment of all the evidence and provided detailed and cogent reasons for according it the weight that she did. The judge was entitled to conclude as she did and her decision is accordingly upheld.

Notice of Decision

20. The making of the decision of the First-tier Tribunal did not involve a material error on a point of law requiring it to be set aside. The decision to dismiss the appeal stands.

Anonymity Order

The Anonymity Order previously made is continued.


Signed: S Kebede
Upper Tribunal Judge Kebede

Judge of the Upper Tribunal
Immigration and Asylum Chamber

27 October 2026